Tom Brady Or Adrian Peterson??

Question

Here's the deal, i have to franchise one of these guys, who should i keep?? i know they both have awesome years last year but can they really do what they did last year this year??

Answer 1

Hmm Tom Brady last years mvp super recievers and o line and like 5 4k yards passing years. or AP with 1 good year with getting injured.

Answer 2

Tough call, hopefully you don't have to make it yet. I would have to pick AP if it was up to me and they needed a decision now.

Some things to consider:

Does either cost you a higher draft pick?

This one is not going to matter a whole lot because you are in a bad position of having to drop one of them and the other will likely be the first overall pick in your draft. With both of these guys on your team, you should have made the playoffs but sadly both put up bad numbers during those weeks. So you are probably in the position of having one of the last picks, so higher rounds are even more important for you to draft in. I would lean towards whatever guy costs you the least as far as draft round.

Who are the other teams keeping?

There should be the normal run on RB’s, so AP’s value is heightened. If you can find out whom everyone else is keeping than you will know who will be available in the first few rounds of the draft. If  there is a run on QB’s and Manning, Romo and Brees are all kept, then you should have better options at RB, though not on the level of AP and depending on where you draft could consider keeping Brady.

Is it possible to trade one of them for another teams draft pick?

Unlikely, but depending on your league set up, see if you can draft one of these guys to the team that has the first pick in the draft for their draft pick. Then you just let them pick between the two and you can still keep one of them and take the best player available in the draft.

Keep tabs on the news out of training camps and pre-season games to help you in making a decision.

Also, if Favre ends up in MIN, I think AP gets more of an edge over Brady as teams won’t be able to stack the box against the run.

Answer 3

i would take A.P cuz there are plenty of QBs out there but not many RBs besides Peterson and Tomlinson

Answer 4

Brady. Brady. Brady.  I like in order:

1. LT

2. S.Jackson (just wait and see!)

3. Brady

Good luck!

Answer 5

Tom Brady cuz he will have an amazing year like every year he has great wr great OL that can protect him and hes not injury prone and AP is so id go with Tom Brady and theres lots of good RB"s that u can get in the 2 or 3 round like Grant Lewis Barbar Jacobs maroney etc....

romo payton brees and brady are all gone in the first 2 rounds

take Brady AP will get injuried and Brady wont

Answer 6

i like both but i would have to go with peterson. after the break out year he had last year as a rookie, you cant pass him up