Tom Brady and Peyton Manning

Question

How is Tom Brady considered the best QB in the NFL? The guy has had it made his whole career. First couple of seasons he had arguably the best defense the smartest coach(and most cheating coach) in Bill "the camera Man". And now he gets the most dangerous weapon in football, Randy Moss. Don't get me wrong the guy is good but I don't see him being better than Peyton Manning. Manning is consistant. In his 10 year career there has only been one season (besides his rookie career) that he didn't throw for over 4,000 yards. He is a genius at Quarter Back. It's like he knows exactly what the defense is thinking. But still Tom Brady gets all the hype that he is the best. What do you think?

Answer 1

exactly tom brady just broke the touchdown record the year after peyton broke it and on fantasy football tom brady is number and had a way better rating the peyton manning

peyton manning would beat tom brady anyday if they had a throw off manning is number but tom brady is just more popular

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

Answer 2

I totally agree I think its because brady has the 3 superbowls and the nfl passing TD record. But they fail to realize that until Brady had all these weapons he wasn't statisticaly better than Peyton. Plus most of Brady's hype is because of the media just like tony romo.

Answer 3

yea peyton manning is better than him, and so is brett favre lol lmao

Answer 4

i disagree. i know brady's overall numbers arent as impressive as manning's but you cant compare them as easily. manning has had marvin harrison during all of his career, then he got wayne and eventually clark, (hes always had incredibly talented players around him, plus a great oline) then brady on the other hand never had a solid receiver (maybe deion branch but he is nowhere near harrison or wayne) until last year with moss and welker bradys primary targets were kevin faulk and troy brown. what you say about the defense is true , NE's defense has been one of the best recently and belichick has been one of the best coaches for a while, but i never see bellichick running the two minute drills during postseason games, nor the defense. both guys are great qbs and are for sure in the top 10 list of best qbs all time. no metter who you are a fan of (patriots personally) but you have to agree that both guys are great maybe one a little better than the other.  

Answer 5

Brady is better,im not saying this cause im a patriots fan im saying this because brady never had good receivers around him until now,manning always had weapons

brady can play indoor and outdoor in any weather manning is s**+ty in the snow and rain

Answer 6

whatever happened to respect u guys talk about him like he didn't even have to work for it lets not forget that he had virtually 0 pro-bowl wide outs until 2003 (Deion branches second year) and manning has always had at least 1 consistent wide receiver or tight end and he had a great 0-line last year was when brady finally had some pro-bowl wide receivers and he put up manning like numbers I'm a patriots fan and ive been saying the same thing for about 4 years "give brady some the same receivers as manning and he will put up similar if not better numbers"

and #2 he got 3 super bowls before he hit 30 only half his career is over and if he plays his cards right he should retire with possibly 7 rings on his fingers shattering Montana's record of 4 manning has struggled to get 1 and hes a year older than brady but agree about the coach part belichick is just a genius hes a football god hes brought a team from 10-6 to 16-0 in just 2 years from 5-11 to 11-5 in one year and from 9-7 to 14-2 in one year but manning and brady rivalry is similar to montana and marino of the 80's and 90's exept manning and brady are in the same conference but in all due respect i gata rate my top 4 of all time as such 1 brady 2 marino 3 montana 4 manning

Answer 7

Give Peyton the kind of team Brady has and Peyton would blow Brady's stats clean out of the water.

Answer 8

brady

Answer 9

because brady is clutch - for the most part he can deliver a game winning driver (took the lead from the Giants in the SB they just took it back)

you really cant compare them though. using your argument that Brady has had a better D that is the same reason why Manning has higher stats - he needs to put up big numbers (at least earlier on) to win games while the Pats could run the ball and Brady just managed the game.

Also Brady already won 3 rings - took Manning a lot longer to win his first (and he did have a very bad few playoffs game the year they won in fact his DEFENSE bailed him out remember the Chiefs game and Ty Law?)

Basically they are both great but tough to compare different teams different offenses (plus Brady did more with less Manning has had years to build chemistry)

Answer 10

I always take Peyton over Brady.  I think last year was a fluke for Brady and especially Moss.  Once things don't go as well for Moss he will pout and not give his best, as is his history.  Peyton has better overall receivers and a much better running back.

Answer 11

i feel exactly as u do, not to mention brady had the most clutch kicker while manning for years had the worst in the clutch kicker(vanderjagt)

and brady has arguablly the best line in the nfl

we saw what brady can do when his line breaks, and he sucks

manning is way better in all areas, brady is just an overrated qb who stumbled into an amazing team

alright to all the retards who say brady is better your wrong

he sucks when his line breaks down, he doesnt put up great numbers unless he has a guy who runs a 4.2 40 and can jump almost 50', he has to use a camera to beat THE JETS, and btw it took brady a lot more attempts to get manning's record(70 more attepts, and he had a worse qb rating then manning when he broke it), c'mon guys dont lie, we all know manning is better and PLAYS FAIR FOOTBALL, HE DOESNT CHEAT, brady b*****s

Answer 12

http://getininfo.izotekizolasyon.com

you can get much information in this website,stay a minute in website and check anyone link at a time,you can aslo get your answer in Google Search in this website, which has helped me alot