Tony Romo Or Payton Manning?

Question

Ok, im a hardcore dallas fan. My bro thinks that Payton Manning is better than Tony Romo. I think otherwise. What i want to know is who is better from when Tony Romo started.

Answer 1

tony romo is good but he sometimes makes mistakes like other quaterbacks...

they said tony romo is going to be better than brett favre..

Manning is alright too because they won the superbowl last year thats why people say that the two Manning are the best quaterbacks but i dont think so...

Answer 2

I'm a Dallas fan, but I'll take Peyton Manning over Tony Romo simply because Peyton has gotten the job done when it really mattered: in the playoffs. Romo still has yet to win a playoff game in his career.

Answer 3

dude.. is that even a question??

manning has broken, and set records

romo hasnt done jack

not even a superbowl ring...

come on

Answer 4

They work in two different systems.  Romo is very good, but I'll take Peyton.

Answer 5

ROMO-- especially after he wins the Superbowl !

Answer 6

Peyton - no question.

Answer 7

easily manning.

Answer 8

Peyton Manning easily. Only one other QB in the league comares to Manning, and it isn't Romo.

Answer 9

  I think Romo has learned from his mistakes, and this year is no doubt going to be his year. I don't think Peyton will have as good of a season he did a year ago, and injuries are the main cause of it.

Answer 10

Peyton Manning

Answer 11

i love dallas and romo is better you bro is a stupid head

Answer 12

Ben Roethlisberger

Eli Manning

Romo is good, but chokes in the big game

Answer 13

I'd say that Manning is definitely better.  It's not even a contest until Romo does it for about 9 more years, wins 12+ games year after year, wins a Super Bowl, throws 50 TDs.  Oh yeah and starts every game for 10 years.  So as you can see there is still some ground to make up.  Even if you mean who is better the last two years, it's still Manning:

Manning: 8400 yards, 62 tds, 23 ints (won Super Bowl following 2006 season)

Romo: 7100 yards, 55 tds, 32 ints.

Answer 14

Peyton is way better than Romo.  

Answer 15

Peyton is better