Tony Romo or Peyton Manning?

Question

This question has been asked for the past couple of weeks now, and now i have decided to ask the people... who is a better QB overall Manning or Romo?

Answer 1

Peyton Manning by far. i think Tom Brady and Peyton Manning are the two best QB right now, either one could be argued as the best personally i think Brady is but Romo? no he's not better than Manning.

Answer 2

ROMO ROMO ROMO ROMO ROMO

romo can scramble and throw on the run

Answer 3

I'm a Cowboy fan,been one since Roger Staubach was quarterbacking the team,but I don't think Romo is yet in the caliber of Peyton Manning,maybe in the future he'll be ranked with Manning,but right now,he hasn't achieved what Manning has,and even then it might be difficult,because Manning is still not through playing great

Answer 4

Manning.  He has many year of good numbers romo has one

Answer 5

If you're talking fantasy value it's Romo, but if I'm putting a team together for a championship it's Manning.

Answer 6

until Romo wins a playoff game, he is just a good QB.

Manning by a long shot. Future HOF Player....  

Answer 7

manning hands down

romo has to prove himself for a few more years in a few big games

be nice if he knew how to hold a snap in the playoffs for a game winning field goal lol

Answer 8

There is absolutely no comparison here - Manning is by far the superior QB.

Answer 9

Not even close, Manning.  I can't even believe you would ask that.  Manning is one of the best of all time.  Romo is the flava of the month, a pretty crappy one at that.

Answer 10

Without question Peyton Manning, unlike Romo, he can win in the playoffs.

Answer 11

Manning is my pick also! I love the Colts and Manning is my hero!

Answer 12

i think that romo can be better most of the time but sometimes manning comes through

Answer 13

Um...I'd have to say hands down Manning on this one.

Romo is just starting out, so he obviously doesn't have the same amount of time Manning has in the league. However, he has yet to win a post-season game. Manning is great at reading a defense, consistent with his performance and has great accuracy.

I think Romo has a lot to prove before he's mentioned in the same category as Peyton.

Answer 14

r u kidding mannig all the way!!!!! romo is good but peyton has the ring and the experiance unlike romo who hasnet won a playoff game 0-2 but romo is still pretty good

Answer 15

Until Tony Romo wins a big game you have to go with Peyton Manning. Because Romo is 0-2 in playoff games. Peyton Manning is pretty good in big playoff games but I think this year Tony Romo will finaly win a playoff game. If you just want to know in the regular season I will say Tony Romo especially in his first few games as starter.

Answer 16

Payton. I'm tired of all these pretty boy QBs being compared to other QBs  like their looks add to their quality of play. Please.

Answer 17

Romo is over-rated and over-hyped just like the Cowboys!!

Manning is a proven QB who has the stats to prove it along with a Super Bowl Championship!!!