Trade Frank Gore for Marshall Lynch?

Question

i have gore but heard some bad things about him this year, would it be a good deal to trade him straight up for lynch?

Answer 1

Yes, I'd much rather have Lynch than Gore.

Answer 2

i might do it but there is a qb situation in san fransico so they can possibly running the ball more until the qb situation is figured out. but it still a good trade but see if you can maybe get something more out of that besides lynch

Answer 3

Frank Gore has only had one good season and has gotten hurt every year.  Lynch is a 2nd year guy with a mediocre qb.  He will get a lot of carries.  Definitely hook up this trade.

Answer 4

Frank Gore first 2 matchups are against the cards and seahawks, Lynch's first 2 games are against seahawks and jacksonville.  After the game yesterday got to believe that gore's value went up some.  49ers and martz was doing a great job moving the ball against the bears.  and gore had 51yards on 8 carries.  I'd wait till at least after the first 2 games.  lynch's value should be low after that jacksonville game, and you should be able to get more value at that point.  

Answer 5

thats tough they both have had 1 good season(even though lynch has only played one). and they both have mediocre QBs. i think i would take lynch however because I like his playing running style more. I saw him a lot last year and he amazed me everytime.

Answer 6

I would do it, and even see if you can slightly upgrade your WR's in a package deal and send out Gore and a weaker WR and see if you can get Lynch and a little better WR from the other guy.

Maybe I'm just joining the Frank Gore bust bandwagon, but I don't believe he will play well this year