Trade Help Needed ASAP?

Question

Almost all 10 the teams in my head to head league have 3 closers. I have 4 including Isringhausen. The only team with 2 closers has offered me Giambi for Jenks. I have been losing in RBI's all year for some reason. Should I accept this trade and put Giambi at my Util spot to help me out offensively? He has been on a tear lately and I am thinking about accepting. I would still have 3 closers. Do you think I should?

Here is my lineup so you can have a better idea of my team:

C - Ryan Doumit

1B - Derrek Lee

2B - Brandon Phillips

3B - Alex Rodrigez

CI - Chipper Jones

MI - Orlando Hudson

SS - Miguel Tejada

OF - Vlad Guerrero

OF - Pat Burrell

OF - Jacoby Ellsbury

OF - Jason Bay

Util - Yunel Escobar

BN - Eric Byrnes

P - Justin Verlander

P - Edinson Volquez

P - C.C. Sabathia

P - Ted Lilly

P - Jair Jurrjens

P - Todd Wellemeyer

P - Jered Weaver

P - Manny Parra

RP - Jonathan Papelbon

RP - Bobby Jenks

RP - Brad Lidge

RP - Jason Isringhausen

DL - Fausto Carmona

Answer 1

ummm NO!!!!

Jenks is probably the best closer out right now behind Marino, and Giambi is streaky so DON'T do it. you'r hurting youself

pick up bourn for Jason Bay, he hasn't been doing anything and is on a team that won't do anything

I like your pitching, especally Jurrjens who is in my opnion the Rookie of the Year and can put up numbers like Volquez

Please Help me with a trade:http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

Answer 2

Try trading Isringhausen for Giambi if you really want Giambi. However, Othere than that I would say don't do it.

Answer 3

Keep Jenks and Papelbon. They're the best. Giambi's not that great anyway.

Once Fausto and Byrnes come back, you should be fine.

I might do the trade if you gave up a different closer.

I'd also pick up Bourn and drop Escobar.

Answer 4

i like your line up, let it ride