Trade-I get Chone Figgins and Roy Halladay and give Edinson Voquez Alex Gordon and Josh Willingham. Should I?

Question

I have Soto, Pena, Kendrick, Gordon, Tejada, Kemp, Conor Jackson, Dejesus, Willingham, Clint Barmes, and Matsui on DL.

I have Dempster, Cliff Lee, Volquez, Webb, Beckett, Wandy Rodriguez, Francisco Cordero, Soria, Morrow, Linebrink and Putz on DL

Answer 1

NOOO. volquez and alex gordon are better than the players ur giving up. plus josh willingham is rlly good ( i think he has over 15 hrs). dont trade.

Answer 2

Volquez is 11-3 this year and made the all star team...i think halladay did too but Volquez is having a much better year plus its easier to excel in the NL which doesnt have the DH rule and is not as good as the AL.  Halladay could be roughed up at any time in the AL while the only teams Volquez has to worry about scoring runs are the phillies and cubs and the cards.

Answer 3

I would do this as this is really Halladay for Volquez as the other players pretty much cancell each other out and Figgins comes in handy with his flexible position elgibility anyway.