Trade help baseball?

Question

In this keeper league, and currently in the middle of the pack. I own HRs and RBIs as it is and need some saves and stolen bases.

You can keep 4 players for the next season, and I plan on keeping Utley, Berkman, Josh Hamilton and Soriano. I also have Milton Bradley and Jose Guillen.

My question is this: Do yo make this trade. I was offered Brian Wilson, SF closer and Carlos Beltran for Josh Hamilton.

DO you think its worth it this year, and do you think giving up a player like Hamilton in a deal like this is worth not having him next year either?

Answer 1

Beltran is very overrated. The Giants stink this year and will stink next year. Wilson will get less save opportunities than most closers. Hamilton may be even better next year than he is this year. I wish someone would trade me Hamilton.

Answer 2

no josh is going to probably win mvp

sf sucks he won't get many saves

beltran isn't as good as hamilton ( 91 rbi to 63)

Answer 3

If it's a Roto keeper league.....I would suggest not trading Hamilton, but if you do decide to trade him, you have to go for the win this year.........go for the juggular and pick up three closers and a basestealer for hamilton dont' waste time with beltran