Trade help.?

Question

is this a fair trade and who gets the better deal?

side a gets- brandon lyon and carlos lee

side b gets- carlos gomez, raul ibanez, tim hudson

Answer 1

Lyon may be in trouble with his closer job after the Rauch trade. Gomez has become almost a non-entity unless you need steals.  It kind of breaks down to Lee vs. the other two. Do you need a SP? Will Hudson help you enough? His Ks are not spectacular.

If so do the trade. Ibanez is serviceable but not great. Since it is uneven, who do you have to drop? The drop is also part of the trade to consider.

Good luck.

Answer 2

Umm side A is most definitely getting the better of that deal by far. If that were proposed and accepted in my league I would veto it.

The guys in trade B suck