Trade i am offered....should i accept???

Question

i got offered

Lynch and Jennings

for

Wayne and McFadden

should i accept??

my team

P Manning

J Lewis

McFadden

S.Holmes

Wayne

A.Johnson

Gates

Gostkowski

Steelers

Cotchery

S Young

J Stewart

D Williams

S Rice

A rodgers

J Hardy

should i accept or reject?

Answer 1

NO keep your team the way it is

Answer 2

Do not accept.  Wayne is much better than Jennings and McFadden is supposed to be one of the better RBs this year.  He's going to tear it up.  One thing you might want to consider is putting Cotchery in for Holmes because Cotchery got a ton of passes last year with Clemens and now this year with Favre he should do amazing.

BK

Answer 3

You are weaker at RB than WR. Picking up Lynch will help even though you are loosing Wayne. Jennings is a good receiver so you won't be loosing much. Cotchery is going to have a huge season with Farve there. Yes, I would accept.

Answer 4

Take it. Don't trust McFadden, and Wayne isn't going to be as great as people think. Remember, Harrison is back to 100%. He'll always be Peyton's go to guy. Jennings is going to have just as good a year, if not better, than Wayne. and Lynch for McFadden is pretty dumb for the other guy if you ask me. It's too hard to trust most rookies in the NFL. Not saying they're all S****y, but the ones who go to the Raiders usually are. Just wait until later in the season when Aaron Rodgers blows up and has an amazing year, and people will start offering you BJ's for him. He's going to be golden. You're team is pretty set, aside from McFadden.

Answer 5

Would the fact that McFadden hasn't played a single game sway you.

Answer 6

you should be worried about that weak a$$ defense...without any COWBOY players i don't see how you have a chance...good luck rookie

Answer 7

This really has a lot more to do with what you think of Aaron Rodgers than anything else.  If you think he's going to be decent or better, accept it.  Lynch will be far better than McFadden this year (don't believe the hype induced from the Post-Adrian Peterson season), but Wayne will probably be heads and shoulders better than Jennings (depending on Rodgers, of course).

Personally, I'm not sure Aaron Rodgers can handle the pressure...