Trade i was offered?

Question

i got offered.....

Webb

Nady

Gregg

for

Cliff Lee

Bay

Sherrill

C A.J. Pierzynski

1B Paul Konerko

2B Brandon Phillips

3B Chipper Jones

SS Hanley Ramírez

OF Nick Markakis

OF Carlos Beltrán

OF Jason Bay

Util Brian Roberts

BN Pat Burrell

Pitching

SP Josh Beckett

SP Aaron Harang

RP Matt Capps

RP Trevor Hoffman

P George Sherrill

P C.J. Wilson

P Tim Lincecum

BN Randy Johnson

BN Johnny Cueto

BN Cliff Lee

BN Todd Wellemeyer

should i accept??? i know sherrill is doing better than gregg, but since i still will have 4 closers, i am kinda not worried.....and i feel webb is a major upgrade over lee.....should i accept or reject??

Answer 1

Yeah, Lee can't keep this up, but Webb can. Your OF is deep, so that loss isn't that bad. Your RP is deep too. Do that trade.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

PLEASE HELP!!!!

Answer 2

I would accept that.

Webb is a top 3 fantasy pitcher and usually does very well in the second half. Lee isn't as good as how he's pitching now and he's already beginning to falter. Since you do have four closers, losing Sherill doesn't hurt too much. I wouldn't even expect Sherill to continue to get save oppurtunities at the pace he is. Bay is rebounding just as planned. Nady is doing well this season, but he really fades in the second half. I would try and get someone else other than him. If you can't, then I'd still accept.

Hope I helped!

Answer 3

Its actually not as easy as V says it is. Its actually kinda tough. Maybe get something you actually need like a Catcher instead of a Closer. You need more hitters. Maybe a 3rd because Chipper is injured and its hard to tell if he will be 100% for the rest of the season.

If thats the best you can get, take it.

Answer 4

Accept it now before the other guy sobers up and takes the offer off the table.  Lee is a sell-high candidate b/c he is pitching better than he actually is.  Webb is god.  Just remember starting pitching is hard to find, and saves are easy to find.