Trent Edwards or Jason Campbell?

Question

Fantasy football-wise,

Who should be better? I got stuck with Campbell as a 2nd QB, and the only other choice out there is to pick up Edwards. Yahoo has projected Campbell to come up with significantly better stats than Edwards, however Campbell looked terrible tonight (I know not to base a pick off of a single regular-season game performance, but really...).

Who would you stick with? Who has the better up-side?

Answer 1

Cambell

Answer 2

I think Edwards has some talent, but he probably won't have much fantasy value until later in the season. Right now, I don't think it matters much, but I would probably pick up Edwards if I had to choose.

Answer 3

it may be one game, but i actually think edwards may have a better fantasy year. also watch out for jt osullivan. I wouldn't pull the gun just yet, just be a little patient. if you're in a league w/ 8-12 teams, almost every year there is a big qb that you can pick up from the FA. kurt warner is just one example from last year, or even mcnabb helped me when he first came on. I can think of many qb's that i've picked up at the end of the year that played at a top 10 level.  

Answer 4

Cambell.  No question