Twilight: Jacob Black or Edward Cullen?

Question

Who do you like better in the book "Twilight" by stephanie meyer: Jacob Black or Edward cullen?

Answer 1

Jacob.

I still love Edward though. He was too over-powering and over-protective for my liking.

Also, without Jacob, we would have never met Seth :)

Answer 2

team edward!!

Answer 3

Jacob, because he has personality and flaws. Edward's too perfect.

Answer 4

I'm team switzerland with a strong, biased love for Jacob. werewolves are more attractive than marble. <3

Answer 5

EDWARD CULLEN!! OF COURSE!! HE IS SO IN LOVE WITH BELLA THAT HE WOULD ACTUALLY GO AND GET HIMSELF KILLED. I KNOW THAT SOUNDS SICK BUT I THINK ITS CUTE!

Answer 6

edward!!...

well at least for bella. i think i wouldn't be able to handle the clinginess. protectiveness is one thing... smothering is another.

Answer 7

JACOB BLACK x 1000000000000000000000000000000000000000... I think he deserves better than Bella. I mean, Jacob is the one that helped Bella when stupid old Edward ditched her.

Answer 8

I like both of them a lot - they're unique in their own way. But I think I'd be too intimidated in Edward's presence - because of his looks, grace, intelligence, and of course, mind reading. Jacob could be a lot easier to get to know, hang out with without feeling awkward and stupid.  

Answer 9

I used to be all about Edward. But now that I have finished the series I definitely prefer Jacob. I realized that he is just more real and funny. I felt like Jacob actually really cared about Bella and wanted her to live a good life. I dunno,Jacob reminds me of like a brother or something. Like a best friend.  

Answer 10

EDWARD....... DUH! sure jacob is more realistic but this is a book about vampires and werewolves! there isnt really any realistic things in this book which is why edward is way better and even realistically edward is way better! jacob is a hairy dog whos a r****d! put him where he belongs: the dog pound!

Answer 11

Edward Cullen i mean come on!

Answer 12

I'd have to say Jacob Black. He's the type of person you meet everyday. Honestly, girls, do you really think you'll find an Edward Cullen? Get real. I love Edward, I really do but Jacob's just so...real. He's someone I'd *want* as a boyfriend. Edward is "perfect", yet he's so...boring. Edward is better for Bella, really he is but Jacob is just someone I prefer.

Answer 13

Jacob Black

i love him! wat do u c in edward!

i m orobably the best jacob fan out there! im alone. YAY ME

Answer 14

edward most def.

haha. i've answered this question so many times!  

Answer 15

EDWARD OF COURSE!!! NO WAY JACOB!!!

Answer 16

Edward, of course... i mean, Jacob is cool and all, but Edward was there first

Answer 17

I love them both.  But I think how she incorporated them both into the story they balance it out nicely.  If I had to choose: Edward by a slim margin.  I like who Jacob ended up with and I don't think he's a pedafile, it makes sense.  Though Nessie seems a little to perfect sometimes, I hope she ends up writing that book from Nessie's point of view because really what are the girl's flaws.  Edward's daughter would be a goody goody.  

Answer 18

Jacob.

Edward sucks-- literally. He has no personality and is borderline emotionally abusive. In real life, he'd be thrown into jail for doing some of the things he did in the books.

Jake pwns. He's got the best personality ever. He's REALISTIC. He has flaws and problems and makes mistakes. He's human.

Smeyer ruined his character in the end of Breaking Dawn, though.

Answer 19

JACOB BLACK! He isnt flawless like Edward and that makes him a completely normal teenager who is the best werewolf (shape shifter) EVER!! (along with seth of course. hehe)

Answer 20

Edward Cullen of course.