Twilight fans-Jacob vs Edward?

Question

Well I was just finish reading New Moon the second part of the book Twilight. I realize that Jacob Black treats Bella better than Edward. Edward is to over protective which is good but Jacob is more down-to-earth and more reasonable.

I fell in love with JcJacoblack because they describe him as a very loving and caring person. He always keeps his promises and always help Bella on the times she needed him. He help Bella forget abaut Edward while she is with him. Although he is a wolf her is nice and more like a human. Jcob always forget bella and always makes her happy. Besides the reason that he is younger than Bella he is warmer than Edward..

LOVE JACOB BLACK

WHAT YOU THINK?

Answer 1

Hello!!

Hmm.... Well, Edward sounds absolutely dreamy but a little....'cold' while Jacob sound very warm and caring but not so hot. =P

This is a hard choice! There should be a Edwacob or Jacward xD

~Lou-chan >w<

Answer 2

yeah finnish the series and then think it over... my opinion....

twilight:edward

new moon:jacob

Eclipse:jacob

breaking dawn:edward

im very indecisive =]

Answer 3

OmG~

I'm not so sure about this one...

But I'm thinking you should finish the whole series, because things change, and you may end up rooting for the other person...

Heres my opinion>>

Edward> Soooooo freaking HOT, but not as nice, and a bit cold..

Jacob> Really nice, but he doesnt sound like he has good looks, and plus, lots of girls have asked Edward out, and I'm not sure, but I dont think LOTS of people have asked Jacob out. >_>

Answer 4

I've read the series... and I've thought it was a hard choice for Bella. Sure, Jacob is funny and a VERY likable character... It's just that I've always gone for characters like Edward... the mysterious type that you can't get tired of and always want more. you might think that way from Jacob, but at times I think Jacob is really... annoying. It is a good series, though, isn't it? I only sleep with books I like (6 so far) and each of the Twilight saga books has been part of them. So, Edward for me. I just find it funny that Bella is Edward's weakness, though, don't you think?

Answer 5

EDWARD WINS HANDS DOWN!!! lol

read the other 2 books and then decide...since the mood of new moon was sooo mopey (is that a word?!?) Jacob would be better as a brotherly figure since he treats her better and comforts her when she is sad.

*yey!! movie in about 4 months!!! XD*

Answer 6

I think if Edward didn't exist then Jacob would have been PERFECT for her. But Edward does exist and so Bella and Edward are meant to be together. I love Jacob too though and i think he should be a part of Bella's life because he's a great best friend.

I tried not to give anything away since you've only read up to New Moon. :D

Answer 7

First of all - EDWARD!!!!  Jacob is SO immature.

Finish the series - then rejudge the two.