Twilight fans! is it me or is he not the perfect Jacob?

Question

I found this guy on imdb.com. His name is Kainoa Kilcher. His sister played Pocahontas in The New World. I think he would have been PERFECT for the Jacob role and he's actually an American Indian. What do you guys think?

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2239827/

p.s. i like Taylor Launter(sp?) but he's not how i pictured Jacob. The only thing that's really great about him is his smile.

Answer 1

I think Taylor makes a good Jacob. Whats wrong with him ? But that other guy would be good too.

Answer 2

Yeah. Possibly If he cut his hair a bit!

Answer 3

I think he would look better if he cut his hair, and I imagined Jacob being bigger (as in more muscular and taller)

I love Taylor but I don't think he's a good Jacob at all. I think he's to small, but that's just my opinion

Answer 4

i pictured him being a little tanner and his bangs a little shorter but other than that i think hes ok

Answer 5

...Taylor Lautner is "actually an American Idian" too. Well, he's part Indian. His mother's side is Indian, his dad's side isn't.

I like the guy you found. Not how I pictured Jake, but I still like him.

Answer 6

totally agree! perfect jacob