United states of india?

Question

Enough blame game is p-layed between centre and the state. It is time every state be responsible. Is it right time for india to adopt americal federal system for the security and smooth running of the country?

Answer 1

Untill our man power will act in a positive manner u may adopt even a thousand of system position will remain unchanged. Try to convence our 100 top leaders that they work with pure heart. They can't treat the generation like a sheep.

Answer 2

let the american keel their systems to themselves. we are more than satisfied with our systems ann DO NOT  need to copy whatever Americans do.

India is comprised of States. which are united as one country, any way

Answer 3

  There is no fault in the system. Fault exists in management and moral values. For success of any system 4Ms are needed :

1)Man Power

2)Money

3)Management &

4)Morality.

  In our system, we have adequate man power and money but lack in management of the things and honesty towards our work and duties.

Answer 4

India's running out of Ghandis. Chaos reigns by 2015.

Answer 5

While I entirely agree with you,it must be conceded

that such a system will not find favor with our politicians and the various political parties for the following reasons:-

1)Small parties like Deve Gowda's JD(S),Ajit Singh's RLD,Soren's JMM,Sharad Yadav's JD(U) and the like will become irrelevant on the national scene.

Consequently,their chances of making money and

playing king makers will be drastically cut ,confining

them to the regional scene where also they are slowly but surely becoming non-entities.That will inflame them to such an extent that they would start playing casteist

politics more vigorously than presently.

2)Next there is the question of responsibility.Now this is one word which is anathema to all parties and their members.If something good takes place,everyone will rush forward to claim credit and  say they are resposible.Should something go wrong,fingers will be flashing and pointing every which way but at themselves

3) Accountability is another word conveniently missing from their lexicon.No one wants to be held accountable

for his/her actions(Except where it will put them in favorable light) leave alone for financial irregularities.

I am getting tired of listing reasons for the system not finding favor,because if I were to continue,I might as well enrol myself for a doctoral program on the subject.

But suffice it to say that except for their personal security,the security and smooth running of the country will always be put on the back burner for manifold reasons.Now,tell me whether you agree with this analysis?If not,may I please know why?

  

Answer 6

well you know nothing could be helped unless we change the way we take politicians... i mean we take in all criminals and stuff for our leaders... who are busy filling their pockets... whatever way we put them Federal states.. or democratic method they will do that... so what has to be changed is them... and that is possible when people like you and me go in there and act responsibly.. we don't vote thinking no one is worth our vote all are same... and so voting happens through those illiterate being who get few rupees for it... so is this way we'll secure ourselves???

Answer 7

i dont think india could adopt that system...........

Answer 8

there is a difference in provinces and states...

india is a country that has been divided into provinces... and not made out of uniting many soverign countries...

when many countries are united then it becomes united states... like earstwhile USSR... UK and USA... it is other way round with countries that got independence from british...  

Answer 9

Sure, seems to work for us.

Answer 10

Yes, I think you are right.