Using Tim Silvia as a measuring stick, Fedor is the best, then Minotauro, then Couture?

Question

Using Tim Silvia as a measuring stick, Fedor is the best, then Minotauro, then Couture?

Answer 1

What's your question......UFC?

Answer 2

actually that math does not work.

almost all of Big Tims loses are due to submissions. Randy is more a submission defence guy not a submisssion fighter. so natrually they would be able to finish him like that whereas randy would not. get it rank'em how ya like but yes fedor is definately number 1

Answer 3

its a matter of opinion. nothing set in stone.

randy beat chuck, chuck beat randy, chuck beat randy...it stopped there...but whos to say randy couldnt beat chuck the 4th time around? so whos to say who's really the better fighter?

Answer 4

Not a lot has changed with the heavyweight rankings. Fedor has always been number one. Here are my current rankings.

1. Fedor

2. Nog

3. Josh Barnett

4. Andre Arlovski

5. Randy Couture

Atfer that it gets dicey. Mir is a big question mark, yeah he beat Lesnar but thats not exactly a great accomplishment. The BJJ expert beat the completely un-experienced guy in his first real MMA fight... really? Lesnar, Velasquez and Carwin all have great talent, but they arent there yet.

Answer 5

no

Answer 6

As a heavyweight, Couture is not top 3. He just surprised Silvia and head butted Gonzaga. If Gonzaga could breathe he would have man-handled Couture.

Fedor is no doubt #1, then Nogueira, and Mir.