Utley, aramis ramirez, mauer for sizemore, wells, sheets, halladay (more to the trade)?

Question

this is obviously a big trade... I am the team with Utley and Aramis, and I need pitching but idk if my infield will be too bad if I do this trade, I have Ryan Howard and Furcal but Beltre and Pudge are potential droppers; so anyways heres the trade

I give:

Utley

Aramis Ramirez

Joe Mauer

Aaron Cook

B.J. Ryan

Jon Rauch

Players i get;

pudge

beltre

sizemore

giambi

wells (last report said he could be back within the next week)

ben sheets

roy halladay

If you dont like that trade what about this one:

I give:

Utley

Jay Bruce

Shaun Marcum

Peavy

I get:

Uggla

Carlos Lee

Volquez

Greinke

I dont like the 2nd trade as much, but which one do you guys like more and the one that you do favor, would you do it if you were my team

things to keep in mind- 10 person league, my team is

c- mauer

1b- howard

2b- utley

ss- furcal

3b- aramis

of- mclouth

of- markakis (whos picking it up, always does second half)

of- carlos quentin

util - bruce

bench - dye

pitching- peavy marcum valverde marmol hoffman

Answer 1

neither trade will help your team. if not it will make it worse. get rid of mclouth. he's overrated. he will flop.

Answer 2

i dint think it is that good

Answer 3

niether will help team

Answer 4

i wouldnt do either

Answer 5

Niether one will help your team.



So don't do either one. The only thing is I would look to get a better backup than Dye for when McLouth's hot streak ends.

Answer 6

Both are bad trades,

Answer 7

Why in the world would you ever consider trading chase Utley? Or Aaron Cook in his best year ever? DON'T DO IT!!! Any trade that gives you Pudge back is a bad idea - who knows how long his health with hold up....

Oh, my ten team keeper league in Scoresheet has an available team - I'd enjoy seeing what kinds of player swaps you would do....

http://www.scoresheet.com/FOR_WWW/P_NL12...

It's team # 5....