VERY lMPORTANT FANTASY TRADE...?

Question

should i trade ichiro, morneau, iwamura, kendrick, and saito for pujols, nady, cj wilson, and pedroia?

I can afford to give up steals and i need power

Answer 1

no pujols is injured right now so he isn't healthy and morneau is going to get hot and saito is one of the best and ichiro can get on base and steal to get a base hit and have ichiro score however the mariners arn't doing hot so i would trade ichiro for a pitcher or another out fielder

Answer 2

no. the only good player coming back is pujols. nady will cool off and possibly get traded. the rest of the players sort of just wash out.

Answer 3

I definitely would NOT do that trade.  There's no reason to give up Morneau (who has a history of heating up during the last half of the season) and Ichiro (who provides solid steals and average - two categories that are very hard to get consistency on).

Answer 4

i don't see you really gaining much power here... Pujols hits about 40 is cancelled out by Morneau's 35-40.... Nady may hit 25 over ichrio but ichiro is just way to much better....

Answer 5

I wouldn't trade the nucleus of my team for the nucleus of somebody else's team.

Answer 6

I think you should do it. Albert Pujols is a rare player and is far better than anyone else in the trade.

If you don't need steals then losing Ichiro won't be a major problem. Wilson and Saito are pretty similar.

Pedroia is definitely an upgrade from iwamura (who will probably be suspended at some point) or kendrick (he's hurt too much). Nady probably won't keep his current pace, but he definitely offers more power than Ichiro, and Pujols is clearly better than Morneau.

And whoever said Pujols was hurt, he hit a pinch hit home run so its obviously not that bad.