Verlander and Carmona for Billingsley and Gavin Floyd?

Question

I have Verlander and Carmona. He will also accept any one for one deal involving these pitchers (V for B, V for F, C for B or C for F). My pitching staff as is weak in Wins, great in K's, and above average in the other cats.

Any advice on the proposed trade(s)? Thanks in advance.

Answer 1

I reccomend u just trade Verlander at this point, for Billingsley. Billingsley has been a pleasant surprise, while Verlander has transformed into a kind of minor league performing pitcher. With ur other SP's, im sure tradin the underpeforming Verlander is a great move, when u get a over-achieving Billingsley in return. Keep Carmona, as he is consistent all season (excludin the walks) and when he comes off the DL, the Indians will increase their wins more.

Answer 2

i wouldnt trade either. Verlanders gonna turn it around. hes a stud in this league, just struggling right now