Vince Young or Matt Leinart?

Question

In college?

Answer 1

Both of these Quarterbacks, in my opinion, havent lived up to be a good starting Quarterback in the NFL. Yes, they have potential to be Pro Bowlers, but they dont get the job done.

Now, if i was to choose out of these two, I would go with Leinart. Why?

He has a Heisman, had a amazing college career, and is just a better all around QB than Young.

Done get me wrong, Vince did good in college too, but Leinart did better.

Answer 2

is that even a question? Vince Young

Answer 3

I'd rather slam my weiner in a sliding glass door.

Answer 4

Leinart will have the better year.  Better team around him, much better set of WRs.  Young is a great athlete and a average, at best, NFL QB.

Answer 5

Matt Leinart in college. He had more potential compared to Young coming into the NFL with much better accuracy but he is turning out to be a bust.

Answer 6

If you mean drinking in a hot tub with a beer bong...Matt Leinhart, if you mean winning and making the playoffs then it's Vince Young. And head to head Vince Young ran shop at the Rose Ball.

But be wary, Vince Young will experience the Madden curse, he did lead the Titans to the playoffs last year, but his numbers sucked.

If Vince Young had Matt's recievers, he would go bananas! Algee Crumpler will give Vince a boost, and Vince doesn't have a Kurt Warner gnawing at his feet.

Point goes to Vince Young.

Answer 7

Well, it now appears that in year 3 Leinart has his head fully screwed on.  Therefore, I think Leinart will prove to be a much better NFL QB than Young.  Young isn't enough of a passer.

Answer 8

Neither has lived up to the hype in the NFL that they had coming out of college.  

Answer 9

Easy Jay Cuter.

He has out played both of those guys so far in the NFL where it counts. Young has played terrible so far and gets credit for the work of the Titans great Defense. And Leinart hasn't done anything at all in two years other than get hurt.

Answer 10

Vince Young for sure.

2 words- Rose Bowl

Answer 11

leinart

Answer 12

young, he made it to the playoffs, rookie of year, and madden cover

Answer 13

I definitely choose my Longhorn Vince. He is 10 times better than Leinart. He can pass and run. I think he will make it at least to the playoffs again this year. In College, it was a close one but since Vince proved Leinart'[s *** he can win a title and he did it a hard way, I'm going with Young.

Answer 14

Vince Young

Leinart is a bust and this yer is going to prove it.

Rose Bowl 2005 thats all i have to say

Answer 15

Vince Young because he is a play-maker and he can get out of tight situations. He is an overall better player than Leinart. In college he was basically a more clutch player than Matt Leinart. I mean look at the Rose Bowl, nuff said.

Answer 16

They both suck.

Answer 17

If you're really asking who was better in college I don't think it's even a competition really. Leinart was a good pocket qb and everything, but VY was one of the best college qb's of all time. He took a texas team that was clearly not as good on paper as USC and beat them by himself. Vince was the man in college.... He's only slightly better right now in the NFL but in college he was a legend.

It also doesn't help that leinart is a whiney little b&*%$ with POS character.

Answer 18

Leinart= Heisman

Young= No Heisman

you do the math

Answer 19

Both of them looked great in college,but they have two different styles so you really can't compare them.

Answer 20

after seeing mat play last thur. MATT ALL THE WAY. More accurate than VY