Was Will Carling better than Wilkinson is?

Question

He had it all, the chin, the teammates who hated him... and he shagged a Princess (albeit a dead one).

Answer 1

Well they share the title of the most boring people on the planet so I suppose it is a draw really. Johnny is no doubt looking for a Princess as we speak.

Answer 2

Will Carling was a very good player.  Wilkinson is a very good player.  Carling was a centre and Wilinson is a fly half.

Both players have exeptional rugby brains, can defend wery well and distributes the ball exellently.

Will has the edge on attacking and Wilknson the edge on kicking.

Overall, Wilkinson will most probably win more games by kicking than Will have won by attacking rugby.

My vote is for Wilkinson.

Answer 3

this is to peter h.  what the h**l are you talking about do you live on the same planet as humans,  or do you know a different will carling to me.

Answer 4

yeah,

I heard he had a multicoloured p***s which has to count for something.

But...

Any man who lets this happen should go home and never come out again

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03gpzFZad...

Answer 5

There's absolutely no question whatsoever Will Carling is the greatest rugby player who has ever lived. He was brilliant. Pure genius on the field. They were the glory days.

Answer 6

no wilkenson best