Was offered this trade....thoughts?

Question

trade michael young and dice-k

get back manny ramirez.....i was thinking of putting in sherrill for dice-k....would u do it?

My roster:

c-McCann

1B- Fielder

2B- Utley

SS- Escobar

3B- A.Ramirez

OF- Berkman

OF- C.Lee

OF- Hart

DH- Jay Bruce

sp- dice-k

sp-hudson

sp-dempster

sp-grienke

sp-pettite

rp-jenks

rp-lidge

bench-kemp, conor jackson, michael young

bench-galarraga, myers, campillo, sherrill, liriano

Answer 1

why are you starting escobar over young? anyways i wouldnt do it cuz dice k gets a lotta wins when he is playing. if i were you i would MAYBE offer escobar and dice k for ramirez but not young and dice k

Answer 2

I say don`t do the trade, because you need dice-k because you wouldn`t really have a good replacement for him.

You`re outfield is already great, and I don`t see any way to even improve it anymore.

You drafted an excellant team, you will definately go deep into the playoffs. Keep your team the same, unless any serious injuries, because that team can win all by itself.