Was the Kirk kick through the goal or what?

Question

Everyone bar the goal umpy thought so.

Answer 1

It doesnt matter cos Swans cheated, they had 19 men on the ground at the end of the match. 4 points should go to the Kangas.

Answer 2

it was a goal

Answer 3

no way touched!

woo kangas!!

Answer 4

it looked like a goal but i really dont know

Answer 5

The fact that he knocked it back towards play and it still hit the goalside of the post showed that he must have been over the line when he touched it otherwise it would have been knocked back into play. Every one around the ball thought it was a goal.

Answer 6

Doesnt matter does it the game is all done and dusted anyway

Answer 7

who does this ANDY K think he is;

mate the 19 men on the field is separate to the question being asked

i was behind the goals when he scored, all us swans supporters went up and thought it was a goal

even kirky did as well

ps wat were harvey and rawlings doing as the siren went, they thought thay won or what!!!!

Answer 8

No. It was not a goal.

The goal umpire was perfectly placed to decide - not sitting in his loungeroom with a beer in his hand!

Answer 9

just for your information there were only 4 free kicks more to north (13 - 17)

there were a few frees on both sides that left me wondering

Answer 10

It clearly went through...the goal umpire made a mistake...oh well....Sydney probably won't make it into the top 8 anyway...good match though...if only Moore kicked at least one of the 2 cances he had....

Answer 11

Not sure about that one but there was another goal that was awarded to sydney that I thought was clearly touched. I was right there and it def touched by harding i think.

Answer 12

nah, it wasnt a goal. and hamish or whoever touched the ball clearly touched it before it went through. anyway it was payback for the swans having an extra man on field. were all even now.

Answer 13

Most definitely a goal which, as it now turns out, would have made a considerable difference to the result of the game!!! We taped the game and have played this scenario, frame by frame (over and over again), and it was most definitely a goal as the ball was welI and truly over the line before the touch occurred!!!!

I personally thought that the overall umpiring was outrageously bad and very biased against Sydney. Oh well-the Swans are still in the top 5 and it is only the end of Round 6, so there is a long way to go yet!!!