Was this a good offer?

Question

MY proposed trade:

I GIVE:

RB Adrian Peterson ( MIN )

QB Matt Hasselbeck ( SEA )

WR Steve Smith ( CAR )

THEY GIVE:

RB Marion Barber

QB Peyton Manning

WR Chad Johnson ( CIN )

do u think he will accept?

Answer 1

I asked about who I should pick up and Adrian Peterson was the one that most people said will be a bust and he'll go through a "sophomore slump". I sort of believe them so I would do this if I were you but I'm not sure if the person you're trading to will accept.

They might, but I wouldn't if I were them.

Answer 2

Barber is a great back, but not A-Pete.

Peyton is arguably the top QB.

Ocho CInco, if settled down, is a top WR, so is steve smith though.

Because of the QB difference i give you the edge/

are all TDs 4pts?

Answer 3

yea i think so steve smith is just as good as chad,perterson is way better than barber and peyton mannig is better than hassleback so its fair

Answer 4

that guy has do be the dumbest guy in the world if he accepts

Answer 5

I would be careful about this trade,mostly because that you are losing Adrian Peterson. You do get some great,talented players in Manning and Johnson.Depending on whether Harrison stays healthy,will affect his play but nevertheless,Manning is the better passer. Ocho cinco is just  better than Smith.If he accepts,nice trade.However there is always a smart fantasy owner that may say no.

Answer 6

I wouldn't do it.

QB is the only position you win in. RB u give up AP for Barber. I think you will lose BIG in that one  &  you also lose at WR. I think that with a the offences of line coming back at 100% and QB coming back Steve Smith is the Panters first choice on offence. As for the Bengals they have T.J. Hosh...wish is a #1 WR in 98% of the league. So Chad catches will drop a bit.  

good luck

Answer 7

Well I don't think so seeing Manning is way better than Hasselbeck and Chad Johnson is better than Steve Smith becuase Carson Palmer throws better than whoever the Carolina QB is so Ocho Cinco will get more touches. Maybe if you spice the trade up he/she will accept.

Answer 8

Sorry man but I dont think he'll accept unless he really likes Adrian Peterson.  Barber and Peyton are both first round picks, probably his first two picks, no player is worth two first rounders, not even LT.  Offer it again but go for one of his other receivers besides chad johnson, maybe then he'll accept.  The best thing about having Peyton on a team is that you almost never need a backup QB until his bye week because he never misses a start.  This frees up space to stockpile a sleeper WR or RB.

Answer 9

Withdraw immediately.

Adrian Peterson's season is going to dwarf Barber's

Same goes for Steve Smith vs. Chad Johnson

And Hasselbeck is just as good as P Manning, better if you look at their schedules. keep what you got.

Answer 10

No that's a terrible trade.

Answer 11

I dont think he will but theres a chance...

Answer 12

peterson wins over barber

manning over hasselbeck

Johnson over smith

peterson is worth a lot so i would go for a peyton manning and barber and throw in hasselback for johnson

you could keep smith but hes been a dud lately