Was this a good trade? Huge TRADE!?

Question

i traded-or gave

Josh Hamilton , Brandon Webb and Miguel Tejada

I recieved Carlos Zambrano , Jose Reyes and Roy Halladay

did i get ripped off or did he or is it comp. even

thanks.

Answer 1

I think you made a good deal.

Answer 2

Shouldn't have traded Josh Hamilton!!!!!

Answer 3

You got him.  Good job.  Halladay is returning to be his old form.  Z is always solid.  Reyes will get steals.  Player for player you got him becuase Tejada is easily the worst player in the bunch, although he's having a good season this year.  It's easy to hit in NL central though, it's got all hitters parks.  You should feel good about this deal.

Answer 4

depends on what your strengths already were. Overall you'll get more Ks, likely more wins, more runs scored, and more stolen bases. Though you will see a decent dip in your power numbers.

Answer 5

I think it was a fairly good trade but pretty even

Answer 6

its kinda even you get better pitching and he got better hitting from the trade

Answer 7

You got two solid starting pitchers and gave up one.  You got one, IMO, slightly overrated position player in exchange for one excellent one (Tejada) and the hot rookie, who very well might fade in the second half.  Good pitching is hard to find, and there will be free agent hitters out there that have been so-so so far and get hot the 2nd half.  I think you got the edge here, providing Halladay avoids his historic record of injury, and if you can grab a good free agent, maybe a big edge.