Were these good trades?

Question

Jamal Lewis (back up rb), Joey Galloway (back up wr), and Chester Taylor (back up rb) for Darren McFadden

AND

Michael Turner (starting WR/RB)

Matt Forte (back up RB)

Derrick Mason (back up WR)

Brandon Marshall (back up WR)

Answer 1

Jamal Lewis is not a backup under ANY surumstances, but i wouldnt do it just because u all the players you are offered are risks

Answer 2

I would advise you to stop trading, because you really suck at it. The fist trade isn't that bad, only if you're in a keeper league. If not, then you got hosed. McFadden is a great RB, but the Raiders have 2 other capable RBs to run the ball. Fargas and McFadden will probably split carries, while Bush will get goal-line and short yardage carries. Lewis is the only RB on the Browns (also they have a better OL). So, he will get much more carries and TDs than McFadden.

And, for the 2nd trade, I've never seen a worse trade in my 10 years of playing fantasy football. I wouldn't even give up Brandon Marshall (with his 3 game suspension) straight up for Roy Williams. You gave up 2 starting RBs and 2 go to WRs for one WR who is just ok. You could have gotten much more with those players.  

Answer 3

i have never seen worse trades in my life.  Jamal Lewis  shouldnt have been traded alone for Darren McFadden but you gave him 3 players for him, lol.

And you traded off 4 players for Roy Williams, you must not have an approval process in your league this would have never flown.  Its almost like you were trying to make the other guys team better while killing your own.