What's better MLS or Primera A?

Question

We all know MLS is no match for the first division,but what about Primera A?I would like to see clean games with no crooked refs.

Answer 1

Definetely Primera A.

U know what I wanto see? MLS vs fuerzas basicas de Chivas y Atlas.

Now THAT would be a close game

Answer 2

primera a

Answer 3

This is a hard one...........im gonna have to go with...........Primera A

Answer 4

i give it a tie

mls is good but doesnt beat fmf

Answer 5

plz any prepa(high school) soccer team from mexico is better dan mls

Answer 6

dude the mexican 3rd league is better than the mls

Answer 7

Well the Mexicans in the MLS are the only good ones.

Primera A is the WINNER thought.

Los de la MLS son Putos. Not the Mexicans thought

Answer 8

Primera A is the WINNER thought

the mls sucks

Answer 9

the mexican dude above me has it wrong the little "putos" as he says are the mexican ones :]

Answer 10

mls probbly by a little

Answer 11

supsam you are pretty stupid did you even watch the superliga

the mexican teams would have destroyed the mls teams if it wasent for the horrible crappy worst refs in the world who only helped the mls teams

Answer 12

here comes the thumbs down haha....one thing i hate about yahoo answers is that if people dont agree with you then its thumbs down no matter what you say.  

no match huh? Why dont you DOMINATE the MLS with your first division then you can ask this question. Like i said earlier to a similar question, MLS from the past year and a half against mexican first division clubs

12W 9L 7T

so i guess you cant say that the MLS is NO MATCH for the mexican first division.  I am one of the few MLS fans who admit that the MLS is not better than the FMF. HOWEVER, MLS is not too far behind at all. Id even say that the FMF should be worried about the MLS over the next 2-3 years as the Collective Bargaining agreement rules for MLS are about to expire this season.  So expect an immense increase in the salary cap and larger player rosters next season as new rules are established for MLS.

I would like to end by saying this one word Mexican fans hate "Superliga".  Pachuca won last year by getting past the Dynamo through shootout and the same method for the final against the Galaxy.  This year must have been very embarrassing as no mexican teams were in the final.  I know that the mexican teams were in pre season form but if MLS is "no match for the first division" like you so eloquently said, surely the mexican teams would overcome that since again MLS are "NO MATCH"......haha no match huh? As for clean games, remember atlante vs New England Revolution during superliga semis. Tell me which side was playing clean.

Answer 13

i'd disagree with mostly all of you. for one the superliga is played at a time when mexican teams are starting their pre-season and factors are evident when it comes to conditioned players to players that are starting to prepare themselves for the upcoming season. another thing FMF has enough teams to be able to have relegations meaning that a team who does poorly for several seasons may be dropped down to a lower division something that i believe doesn't happen in the MLS. i do agree that the MLS is getting stronger than the FMF, but at this point i'd say that FMF is the stronger league than the MLS, for one thing MLS teams aren't invited to play in as many tournaments as are the FMF teams which only shows that when european teams that come and do their pre-season training in the U.S is when they actually do get the chance to see where they stand against good teams. i have yet to hear or read that an MLS team play in the World Cup of Clubs so given that i'd say that Primera A is indeed a better league compared to the MLS.

in regard to the crooked refs you have to consider that not all refs have the same criteria for tackles or knowledge of the games as some refs. although Mexico is known to have the best refs in our part of the globe. we have to also consider whether or not they are actually favoring a specific team when they may have made a simple mistake unless it's that obvious where you can tell that a ref is favoring a specific team. but some mistakes do lead to the game getting out hand and allowing for certain fouls to go unpunished. it almost always depends on the refs to maintain control of the game and make sure the game is fair.

in regards to the atlante vs new revolution game, you have to consider that Atlante had a legitamite goal removed from the by the ref. i do admit this year mexican teams didn't do too well. but until i see an MLS team any other tournament other than the super liga is when i'll agree that MLS is a better league til then Primera A will be superior to the MLS for that reason and for the reason that it doesn't have enough to teams to have regulations so the competition is just about winning the league. i almost forgot has any MLS team won Champions cup? nope so that should definitely answer your question if i haven't done so already.

Answer 14

I think la 3rd division is better than the MLS right now!!!!!!

Answer 15

tuberos of colima i bet they can beat any mls team right now

Answer 16

I don't know but I'm pretty sure that Club Tijuana Xoloitzcuintles De Caliente would beat the Galaxy right now.

Answer 17

USA>MEXICO....

that's all i got to say about that.

Answer 18

In regards to ALEJANDR...   statement:

"but until i see an MLS team any other tournament other than the super liga is when i'll agree that MLS is a better league til then Primera A will be superior to the MLS for that reason and for the reason that it doesn't have enough to teams to have regulations so the competition is just about winning the league. i almost forgot has any MLS team won Champions cup? nope so that should definitely answer your question if i haven't done so already."

I recommend you do research before posting statements like this one.  It makes you look ignorant.

For your information MLS clubs have won the CONCACAF Champions Cup: 1998 DC United and 2000 LA Galaxy.

DC United also won the Copa Interamericana Cup in 1998.

*****Mr. "JACK IN THE BOX"

My answer was to ALEJANDR...statement!!!!!  Didn't you understand what I wrote above?????

I didn't care to answer your question!!!!!  However I did feel like responding to ALEJANDR...statement.  So I did!!!!!  

You can answer your own question!!!!!

Reason for feeling this way is that I know Mexican fans will never give the US National Team nor the MLS the credit it deserves!!!!!  As a whole the United States of America has been more successful than Mexico in the sport of Football (Known as Soccer in the USA).  Argue all you want, but the USA has more world titles!!!!!  Men, Women or even Youth Teams!!!!!

The reason Mexican Fans dislike and will not give respect to the USA is that Football(Soccer in the USA) is the only sport that Mexico cares about and puts all of its APPLES in one basket for...While the USA doesn't value Football(Soccer in the USA) as much, because we focus on several other sports.  Such as Baseball, Basketball, American Football, Hockey, Tennis, Golf, Swimming, Track & Field, ETC, ETC, ETC... As you can see in the OLYMPICS the USA does well in just about all sports!!!!!  

So say what you want...But the reality is that the USA as a whole is better at the only sport that Mexico cares about (Football, known as Soccer in the USA); it hurts!  We know and we are sorry for your lose!!!!!

USA has more #1's on the World Stage(not regional stage) than Mexico.  See link below!!!!!