What's better fat eyeliner pencils, or the skinny ones??

Question

I just wanna know because some of my friends say the big thick ones are better but to me they're the same...??

Answer 1

skinny ones are easier to draw fine lines with, to get the eyeliner exactly where you want it to go (and NOT where you DONT want it) and they are harder to mess up. also, the line generally comes out darker with skinny eyeliner pencils

Answer 2

i like the skinny ones... my favorite is mac: night club color

answer mine..its easy http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

Answer 3

well with the skinny ones you can do thin line or thick or smoky look, with fat liners can only do thick lines really i just stick with thinner pencil, and if i wanna thicker line or a smoky look i use gray or black eyeshadow and agood brush

Answer 4

um using the fat ones makes it easier to put on, so i'd say fat?

Answer 5

it really depends what look you are going for. for preppy- put together look, i like to use the skinny ones. but if you are going for the edgy-er look, the big thick ones look great. it is always nice to have both of them though.

Answer 6

It depends on the look you are going for. I personally like the thin ones because more layers can make a thick line, whereas fat ones always create thick lines so there aren't as many options.

oh and a surprisingly good pencil is seriously cheap-the Rimmel soft kohl kajal eye pencils. They are only about 3 dollars and work GREAT!

but it has to say soft kohl-there is a different kind by them that sucks. the good black one is jet black, the bad one is called black magic.