What Sub Will Hit Harder? Alpine or Punch?

Question

What combination will hit harder? a rockford fosgate p3 punch in a normal sized box or an alpine type r in a smaller box?

Answer 1

all depends on the sub and enclosure

Answer 2

it depends on the enclosure and what the rms of the subs are.

Answer 3

Vague descriptions.

Rockford P3 Punch in a normal sized box vs Alpine Type R in a smaller box.  Based on the enclosure descriptions, the Type R is at a disadvantage in the comparison.  I'll take the P3 Punch in this comparison.