What are the differences between a Classic Fly Fishing Reel and a Pillar Raised Fly Fishing Reel and who makes

Question

makes the Pillar Raised.

Answer 1

There is no clear definition of a "classic" fly  reel, though some may refer to some reels having "classic styling."  To me, such a reel would have a standard arbor (as opposed to the large arbor reels in fashion now) and simple, round perforations for ventilation.  Some might add that a classic reel should have a simple drag such as a check/pawl system.  Reels such as older production Orvis CFOs and Hardy Lightweights (any in the series) would be examples of classic styling.

Though we don't use the term much anymore, the perpendicular supports between the frame's sideplates were traditionally referred to as "pillars."  Today, most frames are made as a single machined or cast unit.  However, for many years, the frame was assembled from individual side plates that were screwed to the pillars.  Some early reels, and some current reproductions, had the pillars mounted outside the outer circumference of the sideplates.  This allowed the entire spool to be filled with line.  Here's an example of a raised pillar reel:

http://www.peerlessreel.com/raised_pilla...

Functionally, there isn't much difference.  It's really about the style that appeals to the angler.  But a raised pillar reel looks much better on a cane rod than it does on a current graphite rod.