What are your thoughts for the girl who was "born" twice? One sign or two?

Question

*I am just curious on your thoughts, nothing serious* Whats your astrological opinion? :] ..... So if you haven't heard there was a baby girl who was "born" twice she is about 3 months old now........ Long stroy Short: She had a large tumor on her back side so 6 months into the birth they preform surgury in late Febuary: Pisces....To do surgury they only take the little girl half way out of the womb to remove the tumor & leave the upper half of her body still in the womb....it was a success & 10 weeks later she is offically born again on May 3rd: Taurus........So my question is: Do you think it is possible she has two seperate charts? Possibly making her two signs with a mixed personality or no? Do you think she only has one sign, one charts & nothing else? Which birth counts the 'half' one or the 'real' one? A pisces or a taurus or both?.....(I don't have her full info, sorry)........Anyways I just want your thoughts on the subject no big deal or explaination :] Thank you! :D :D :D

Answer 1

I would think that she's a Taurus because when you're born, all of you comes out of your mother, not half.

Answer 2

I would probably think her true chart would be the day she came fully out of the womb...not sure if taking her halfway out to perform a surgery counts as a "birth".  My opinion, anyway.

Very interesting story, though

Answer 3

i think she has one sign because technically she wasnt through developing and they just took her out shortly to remov this tumor but she still was delivered at her 9 month term...so she has one sign

Answer 4

I don't believe she has 2 separate births or charts, she would be a Taurus because that is when she was no longer in the mothers womb.  That's a wild story though, I hadn't heard that.  But your question had me thinking back to a debate some astrologers had about whether someone who had a "near death experience" but came back after being dead, would they be reborn or have a new birthday of sorts?  I don't believe they would as the progressed or directed chart would show where they were in their life at that point.  I am glad that little girl is well now and isn't it a miracle what modern science can do!

Answer 5

Confusing but Great I guess she is Taurus

Answer 6

I would say May 3rd would be her true birth. Technically she had a tumor and it wasn't her fault so that doesn't make the surgery her "birth." Is this making sense? She would be a Taurus. But, maybe i'm wrong and that she has 2 personalities (which isn't exactly possible ..i think). U'll have to wait and see for yourself!

Hope this helped the teeniest bit! Good-luck!

Answer 7

No, there is only one birth - the day they cut her umbilical chord, and filled her lungs with her own breath of life.

However, there is consideration of a pre-natal life which we all have - a different subject all together.  I'm sure hers is very interesting.

Answer 8

She was born right the first time, and would have had the same personality if she'd been born a month earlier.