What brand of black eyeliner doesn't smugde?

Question

I have bought a dozen different brands of eye liner, but they all end up smudging around my eye. What kind should I buy that is easy to apply and doesn't smudge?

Answer 1

MAC..for pencil anyways

Answer 2

I LOVE Clinique's water-resistant eyeliner in natural black.  

It comes in a little silver case and it looks like eyeshadow.  It comes with a tiny brush that you wet before applying.  It's really easy and does not smudge.

Answer 3

revlon colorstay ;)

Answer 4

umm. every single thing smudges. thats y its called being careful && letting it dryy

Answer 5

my mom gets it from MAC... it would be the pencil though.. it works really good

Answer 6

I love Ulta brand make up...I have never had problems with the eyeliner getting smudged and rubbed or whatnot

Answer 7

nars is theee best !

you can get it at sephora.

c[;

Answer 8

revlon colorstay or this from physician's formula its soooooooo good :)

http://www.physiciansformula.com/en-us/p...

Answer 9

I find that the liquid lines are the best, they don't smudge like the crayons or pencils. I have used many different brands of the liquid and don't have smudging problems and it is very easy to apply and I personally think that it looks better too.  

Answer 10

girls are so weird. don't wear makeup

Answer 11

I Found MAC Is Amazing

It Doesnt Smudge (unless you reallu rub your eyes) and is easuly to apply

Answer 12

loreal hip cream eyeliner  

Answer 13

borjous is amazing!

Answer 14

I use eyeshadow for eyeliner and apply it w/ an angled eye liner brush, like this: http://www.sephora.com/browse/product.jh...

I like using eyeshadow over eye liner because it does not smudge. It sometimes doesn't last all day (depending on the color - lighter colors don't last all day) but you can just reapply. I buy the darkest black and apply a thin line of it under my eyes and it usually lasts all day.  

Answer 15

many brands sell waterproof eyeliners which don't smudge (or it is very hard to make them smudge)

so they last longer in the day

Answer 16

Aziza is great! buy the waterproof and it's not expensive either. Yet it comes off easily