What did you hate most about Breaking Dawn?

Question

To those who liked the book and those who didn't... ;]

I didn't liked the book at all , but the thing i most hated was Jake imprinting on Nessie.

Thanks XD

Answer 1

Hmm.

In my opinion it's the fact that Bella got pregnant in the first place, mainly because Stephenie Meyer has already said that vampires cannot get pregant, or be a parent for that matter. But, Suprise! Bella had Nessie.

But Jake imprinting on Nessie was defenitely up there with the first, but if the first hadn't of happened than you know that we wouldn't have a problem.

*sigh*

And it was so promising....

Answer 2

Well, um, *braces herself* I kinda liked it..a lot. I mean, I didn't like how it was written so differently, but I still loved it. However, the first three are certainly much better. I loved them all though.

SQUEE! Midnight Sun/movie! Can't wait!

Answer 3

i thought the ending wuz stupid it was a good riting style and stuff but the story line was pretty bad...idk

Answer 4

i liked the book alot including jake imprinting. i didn't like the fact that they didn't fight with the volturi.

i also didn't like it when emmett had to stop making jokes. it kinda took all the humor from the book.

Answer 5

The fact that Bella got everything she wanted. Don't get me wrong here, I love the Twilight series, and am an obsessed fan myself, but the fact that Bella got Renesemee, became a vampire, skipped the new-born stage of her life, still felt attracted to Edward, got to see Charlie, kept Jacob, and is saved from the Volturi, annoyed me, and caused the book contradict previous books. I mean, there was no sacrifice, and she got everything, it was too perfect!

Answer 6

God as much as i loved the twilight series and breaking dawn, (i read all 4 books in 3 days) i felt that it was DISGUSTING and horrible that he imprinted on Renesmee!!! I mean god i think thats just horrible and makes me want to barf!! But besides for that i loved the book, sorry, I love the romance factor, especially Edward, god if we were all that lucky. Now Im just kinda worried because my little 4 year old cousin is named bella?!?!? If she gets Edward I will go crazy, jk lol. I loved that Bella became a vampire and i wish SM comes out with more books because this story has pretty much became my LIFE the last 3 days!! Last night to finish the last book i stayed up till 2:30 am and then wanted to go back and read little parts!!! I am addicted to these stories!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...

Answer 7

i loved it! but i agree... i thought it was a little wierd that he imprinted on RENESMEE! not nessie sorry but thats lame... i thought the ending could have been beter if jake imprinted on the girl at the lake. but introducing a new character like that, one that has a personality and stuff would have been stupid. plus they wouldn't have been able to shut the volturi up becuase  they wouldn't have had the werewolves and bella would have never known her power... and i really liked her power... so overall i really liked it though.

Answer 8

Yes, that imprinting thing is disgusting. If I were Nessie *laughs at the name*, I'd call 911 and tell them about the pedophile stalking me. Not to mention the fact that Smeyer basically deserted Leah.

But for me, the absolute worst part was Edward asking Jacob to have s*x with Bella. EIGHT YEAR OLDS READ THIS BOOK. Meyer knew that her books were for a young audience, and yet she set this horrible example. Adultery, pedophilia, and s*x are not appropriate for a YA book. When asked about Edward's request, Meyer gave us the usual bullsh*t. She said, "I didn't know he would go that far either." WHAT?! I find it strange that she can't control HER characters in HER book.

Answer 9

The book was o.k. I liked Twilight better. I didn't like how climax had to do with the Volturi coming after them. I thought that was dumb and that she took up almost 200 pages about how why or why not the Volturi was going to kill her family. There should have been a different climax.  

Answer 10

i HATED the ending relationship between jacob edward and bella. it seemed to easy for jacob to just imprint on her daughter. and the fact that a werewolf can just imprint on a half vampire is so unrealistic in their world. i was SO mad that they didn't fight the voultori. it was just really dissapointing.  

Answer 11

Ditto! Jake imprinting was perverted, and Jake used to be such a great guy!

Answer 12

I liked the book but I hated that Bella did nothing to stop Jake.... I think it's disturbing for a 16 year old boy to fall in love with a baby....

Hope this helps :D

Answer 13

Overall, it had a good finish to the Twilight saga!

But when you reali think about it...

Giving birth - SICK!

Turning into a vampire  - GROSS!

The 3 different books - PRETTY GOOD!

Jacob inprinting on Nessie - SICK!  

He can use the sentence 'Yeah, i made out with your Mum!'  - SICK!

No fight with the Vulturi - BORING!

Bella getting all bruised on Esme Island - EW!

Leah having quite a main part then being dropped at the end - WHAT?

Edward wanting Jacob to kill him - NOOOOOO!

Thats about it  =]

Answer 14

I haven't read the book yet :D i hope it is good :D

Answer 15

What I hate most isn't even IN the book. I hate that Stephenie Meyer contradicted herself, then had the audacity to say that she'd been MISQUOTED?!! Uh, WHAT?! A million times? If you knew you'd been misquoted then why didn't you get up and fix the mistake? Hm, suspicious. I also hate how she'd planned that nightmare named Renesmee *shudders* from the beginning and let's not forget the aforementioned. She knew she was going to have that baby, if you can call that thing a baby, from the beginning but she never left the door open for Edward and Bella to be able to have children.

On and on and on in Twilight, New Moon and Eclipse she whined about how Bella would have to give up being a human and the human things--kids, her family, etc.

This brings me to the things I hate IN the book. I hate how Bella got everything she wanted. EVERYTHING. There wasn't anything she DIDN'T get. Oh wait, I think I see something...SACRIFICES. She didn't get to the sacrificing. She didn't sacrifice anything. I have nothing against happy endings, but they have to be realistic and in this novel they were not realistic. She said in an interveiw--Times interview I think--that the only reason it didn't end with the wedding was because life went on and she wanted the book to be realistic and that by not quitting at the wedding she showed how in reality life doesn't end after the "I dos".

Um, okay Stephenie. Well...let's be realistic...people don't get everything they want. NOT EVEN IF THEY'RE EXTREMELY LUCKY!! Let alone getting EVERYTHING and WITHOUT SACRIFICING c**p! That's just waayy too unrealistic.

Even if Bella was going to get everything, the marriage, the baby and carriage, her family, vampirism or whatever, what was the point of all that whining in the first three books? Hm? Hm? What was the point of the love triangle and showing all of the things she'd be missing, but not really missing if she turned into a vampire?

I seriously can't say I get it.