What do you think about American Idol adding a fourth judge?

Question

They're adding Kara DioGuardi as a forth judge on the show. What do you think??

I really HATE this decision - I have a feeling it will ruin the dynamic that the judges have developed over the past 7 seasons.

Answer 1

simon caws answer: this is oposterfis   she is not eragant at all   this is a joke    lol

Answer 2

Certainly, another female perspective will be welcome, or shall I say a sober female perspective! It seems that no one really takes Paula Abdul's inputs seriously especially with her blunders last season. Remember the "your second song" comments on Jason Castro when he has only sung once? He he. But I must admit Paula is good entertainment nevertheless

Answer 3

I dont know how they will handle auditions. If they both vote 2 yes 2 no. I don't know. The 3 is what we are used to but the simon paula randy is nice. But they may be setting it up so one of the 3 judges gets the boot next season and we are used to the new one.

Answer 4

I don't like the decision, it was so much better having just the 3 of them being a judge.  I think it will feel awkward and not as good with 4 judges.  They will probably lose a lot of viewing audiences since everyone likes the 3 of them alone as judges.  With a 4th judge it will not be as fun since it might be split decisions and that will kind of ruin the entire show.

Answer 5

I don't want her as a judge. First of all, who the h**l is she? If they're gonna add a new judge at least make someone that is well known. Maybe a REAL singer? It's a stupid decision. And then a girl? Paula Abdul is all they need. At least make it a guy, a young one, if they're gonna add a new judge. Then she hasent even talked with all of them to see how things would work out. This is gonna ruin the show. I do not like this  idea.

The only reason why they are adding her is because she writes songs for the idols and others. Shes writing songs for Camp Rock2 Cheetah Girls 3 and Hannah Montana the movie. That's the only reason. I don't see why they need to add her as a judge.

Answer 6

Because they don't want the show to go stale.