What do you think about Brad Gilbert (Andy Murray's ex-coach) as a commentator?

Question

I like his Scotish style (not sure if he is from Scotland though) of comment. For instance, in this morning, U.S. time, he slammed all upset-seeds in Wimbledon were finding lame excuse in mental fatigue. He said "It is not fatigue, it is WEAK!!". The other commentators were kind of appalled........

YEAH~ But his admonition with Andy Murray is still there.......

Answer 1

His predictions never materialize.

Answer 2

He Sucks

Answer 3

He's a better coach than he is a commentator.  Some of the things he's said in the past working for ESPN were borderline offensive, and not at all accurate.  He's a smart coach, but he needs to stay away from the cameras and microphones.

Answer 4

I think he is a great commentator. He admits his flaws and makes pretty accurate predictions. I like him. I wonder why Andy Murray would fire such a great coach with so much knowledge of the game.

Answer 5

Brad Gilbert gets paid £375,000 per year to help develop some other British players, and most of them he is involved with are already out, so he is in no position to call anyone weak.

Answer 6

He's alright. I'm pretty neutral about his comments he makes. Just as long as he does not become annoying, I can live his commentary.