What do you think of my All-MLB team?

Question

Starting Lineup

1 – Ichiro Suzuki (RF)

2 – Hanley Ramirez (SS)

3 – Albert Pujols (1B)

4 – Alex Rodriguez (3B)

5 – Alfonso Soriano (CF)

6 – Josh Hamilton (C)

7 – Ryan Howard (DH)

8 – Matt Holliday (LF)

9 – Chase Utley (2B)

Starting Rotation

Johan Santana

Jake Peavy

Chris Carpenter

Rich Harden

CC Sabathia

Bullpen

LRP – Cole Hamels

MRP – Scott Kazmir

MRP – John Smoltz

MRP – Joe Nathan

SU – Mariano Rivera

SU – Jonathan Papelbon

CP – Francisco Rodriguez

Bench

C/OF – Ryan Braun

MI – Jose Reyes

CI – Chipper Jones

DH – Barry Bonds

Reserve Batters

David Ortiz

Manny Ramirez

Prince Fielder

David Wright

Miguel Cabrera

Grady Sizemore

Derrek Lee

Jimmy Rollins

Carlos Lee

Reserve Pitchers

Josh Beckett

Brandon Webb

Roy Halladay

Billy Wagner

Answer 1

Chris Carpenter and Ichiro should not be on it.

Answer 2

Umm, what about Carlos Zambrano?  Not even a reserve?  He could even be your DH.  And I love Soriano, but he's no CF.  Try again.

Answer 3

josh hamilton cant be catcher .put him in left field and take out matt holiday.get a new catcher. then take out jake peavy andchris carpenter. your bullpen is great.take barry bonds out of ur bench, and put in kevin youkilis.take chipper out for jeter. the reserve batters  are good.reserve pitcheres are also good.

Answer 4

You should get rid of Ichiro, Carpenter, Peavy, and Jimmy Rollins (I am a Phillies fan, but Rollins has been dreadful).

Answer 5

It's okay but it could be better.  For example, put A-Rod at his original Short Stop position, and put Chipper at Third Base.  Grady Sizemore should be in Center Field, Soriano should be in Left Field, Papelbon should be the Closing Pitcher, and Utley should be batting much higher in the line up.  Also, there are better Starting Pitchers than Carpenter and Harden.  You should put John Lackey and Becckett in the rotation instead.  Bonds should not be on roster, no matter what, and Pena should be at first base.  A better Designated Hitter choice would be Ortiz.  Now that's a winning team.

Answer 6

Take out Soriano He sucks at fielding. Put Yadier Molina in catcher

Answer 7

get rid of hamilton, ichiro,carpenter,and bonds