What do you think of my photo editing??

Question

Original: http://flickr.com/photos/carrierox4ever13/2717750770/

Edit: http://flickr.com/photos/carrierox4ever13/2716976107/in/photostream/

Original: http://flickr.com/photos/carrierox4ever13/2413761027/in/photostream/

Edit: http://flickr.com/photos/carrierox4ever13/2313742426/in/set-72157606657248611/

Original: http://flickr.com/photos/carrierox4ever13/2762908553/

Edit: http://flickr.com/photos/carrierox4ever13/2405886571/

Do you think I over edit or do you think I am good at editing photos??

Answer 1

i think your edits are well good :) your a natural :) cute cat btw  try picnik.co.uk its a really good editing site aswell :) please can you do some of my questions too :)

hope this helps :)

Answer 2

I think they look good!! Especially the first one! Good job!! :D

Answer 3

I prefer the original on the first photo. Things like nature need to look natural, and I think you can definately tell it's edited.

Again I prefer the original for the first cat photograph. I think it's zoomed in too much, and as a previous poster said, you've over-done it a bit.

The third photo, I do love. I think you done a great job on that one. The way the light falls onto kitty made the overall look of it work.

I've seen far worse examples of over editing (I used to be the worst at this!) and you're definately not a serial over-editer, and if this is a first shot at it then you've done great, but just try and remember what it is you're trying to put across in your photo, and be subtle about it.

Another thing. You had great photos to work from. Try editing some awfully taken images from other people and see how well you can do with them. THEN you'll know if you're good at it or not!

Answer 4

yer good but you zoom in too much

Answer 5

cool

Answer 6

very good!

The areas you choose to highlight really show your perspective.

Answer 7

Congratulations, you know how to use the zoom and crop features in your picture program.

Answer 8

I like 'em. I like the first one the best.

Answer 9

Carriero your photo editing was  good except the first cat photo, you applied to much unsharp mask or sharpen to this photo.

Answer 10

As often as I try, I am not a very good photographer.  You, however, do exceptionally well, I think.  Pet pictures are not easy! I like the originals very much and I also like the results of your editing -- on all three.  I agree with your comment on the flower edit that it could be improved with more texture.  Even so, you achieved much better results than I could do.

Answer 11

its ok nothing super special but decent at that