What do you think of my photo retouches?

Question

What do you think? Good, bad? Maybe even give me a a few tips :]

http://i274.photobucket.com/albums/jj261/gumdrop18/random.png

http://i274.photobucket.com/albums/jj261/gumdrop18/eval.png

Answer 1

They're good, but aren't you supposed to put the 'before' picture first?

Answer 2

nice

Answer 3

what they do wax ther zits!!!!!

Answer 4

You got talent, they are great

Answer 5

They are so freakin good

Answer 6

WOW! ama-ZING! :D

Answer 7

umm its good but i think the first girl would have looked better natural and just with eyeliner around her eyes and color on her lips but the second one defentley needed it all

Answer 8

Sorry but they look horrible and really unnatural.

I can't understand why people say they are good.

"random photos from the internet" sure

Maybe you should ask the owner of those pics the permission to ruin them.

To make skin smooth use Filter / Noise / Median in photoshop.

Btw. I don't want to offend you just make you realize that you can improve.

Answer 9

The first one looks great, almost natural.  The second one is too perfect, making it look a little on the fake side.  Keep up the good work.  You definitely have superior retouch skills.

Have fun

Answer 10

wow nice..they look like wax

Answer 11

I do photo retouching as well.  Only thing is make sure not to loose texture on skin, you can either lower the opacity of your mask and of course don't take all the blemishes away :) like some well position mole.  Also take care of your important edges don't include them in the softening, this is the most common cause of unnatural look.  Edges such us side of nose, nosetrils, lips, eyes and of course eye lashes and eye brows.  Oh and don't make white too white :) unless you're going for a dramatic effect.  Just my constructive suggestions :)

Answer 12

I think they look like they were retouched.

Answer 13

they look really good but kinda fake

Answer 14

w...o...w...!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 15

Well, you definitely hide the blemishes. Maybe a little too much? Just add in some more shade etc. But hey, still good! I couldn't do it.

Answer 16

i think thats pretty cool

Answer 17

a little less affect but it still looks good

Answer 18

they are great

the first one is best

The second one looks a little "made up" but dark skin is more difficult to retouch

Keep up the good work