What do you think of the new american idol judge?

Question

i don't know her name but i don't like her already..

i like 3 judges..

4's a crowd

Answer 1

yeah i heared about  a new judge coming to american idol it could be a good thing or a really bad one, having to women maybe paula will feel awkward because she plays the nice jugde wat will the other women play the mean one so there could be some tension i dont we will see how they work together.paula may feel she cant express herself or it could be a good thing and maybe they can bring something good to american idol something new and fresh. ;p

Answer 2

Too early to say, obviously, since we haven't seen her in action. I know she wrote songs for Ashlee Simpson so I'm kind of wondering what she could possibly know from music. Clearly, she is only being brought in because they need someone to be The Girl and The Nice One and Paula is no longer up to the task. The most interesting part will be seeing how Paula reacts to it. She'll either really shape up or completely fall apart. I can't wait to see which it will be. But I'm betting on the latter.

Answer 3

Kara DioGuardi,

i think she is pretty and she could make the show really interesting..

she seems like a girl version of simon which could get nasty..

can't wait!

Answer 4

As the real Old saying goes, it's "three's a crowd" but I get your point.  I have to see how she does before I judge her.  That's the fair way.

Answer 5

Oh, c'mon, give her a chance.  She might really liven things up.  As long as they don't mess with Ryan, I don't care what they do.  I need to at least see the new judge on the show before I decide.