What do you think of these shoes for an 18 year old?

Question

These dark brown flats: http://www.dsw.com/dsw_shoes/catalog/product.jsp?prodId=166499

This low heel:

http://b.imagehost.org/view/0278/Photo_512.jpg

Do you they're sophisticated and nice, especially for college? I just bought them. Would they be appropriate for formal occasions?

Answer 1

i love the first pair but the 2nd not so much. however yes they are sophiticated looking and i'd say perfect for college. you need sensible comfortable shoes. not s**y.

Answer 2

Ur 18 and going to college..Wear higher heels or sandels alittle more s**y

Sorry but those are alittle oldish

Go sexier

Answer 3

omg..they look like th shoes my nan wears..im sorry but they r hideous!

Answer 4

yea they're both pretty cute, especially the brown ones :) and yea i think they're both practical for college and smart enough for formal stuff.

Answer 5

Neither shoe is bad but  I think they're both too frumpy for an eighteen year old.

Answer 6

the low heel kinda looks granny i would have tryed kitten heel but i like the flats:]

Answer 7

The first one is cute but the 2nd one seems to plain and old looking. You should look at macy's or baker.  

Answer 8

1st one is cute and fashion BUT the 2nd one!?? sorry but theyr like grandmas shoes and they r hideous, dont wear them!

Answer 9

In the first link, I like the purple flats.

The second link "the low heel", I think it looks a bit too old fashioned

and something a 10 year old girl might wear to a piano recital or

what school bands for girls would wear.

Answer 10

The first one is perfect but I'm not that sure about the low-heel one :S

Answer 11

1] love the dark brown flats!

2] the black heels look matronly - I am 52, and I wouldn't wear them!

You can be comfortable, and wear cute shoes!

Try:

black velvet flats

low heeled black sandals

low heeled black slingbacks

black pumps with kitten heel

Answer 12

the top one, no

bottom one, yes

Answer 13

i like the flats but the heels are a little blegh. :[  

Answer 14

yes, yes, yes :) !

Answer 15

Neither are appropriate for formal occasions.  You might be able to pull off the dark brown ones if you are going for a 80s themed casual outfit.  If you try wearing them with a skirt as dressy, then that will look silly.  The black ones are in no way appropriate for an 18 year old under any circumstances.  Those shoes are for 45 year olds who don't care about what they wear to work.  Please take those back!