What do you think of this drawing?

Question

Well actually there are 3, going from 2000 until 2006, it is basically my progression in drawing, granted the third is pretty c**p and is unshaded even though it was the last one;

Ratings would be good for each, thanks and sorry about the small image size.

http://img28.picoodle.com/data/img28/3/8/23/f_tn3AndroidGm_ec6b4f7.jpg

Answer 1

I really like the first one.  It is incredibly detailed and the first one's posture is the nicest.  It looks very professionally done and detailed.

The middle one is alright, I think its better then the last one.  I like how you made some of the parts shaded and faded.

As for the last one, it's posture looks a bit odd.  And the coloring is a bit dull, it could have used more texture.  But it still looks nice.

Answer 2

The middle one is definitely the best, but the first one isn't too bad either.  The third one looks bad mostly because you don't know what you're doing with the computer.  I hope you're not stuck using MS Paint.  Try searching 'Photoshop Tutorials' or 'Painter Tutorials' or tuts for whatever art program you're using and it'll help a lot.

I'd say... 3/5, 4.5/5, and 3/5

Answer 3

They Are Actully Sick Mate !! Well Done I Think The Middle One Is The Best But I Would Give The First Pic 5/10 The Middle One 10/10 And The Last One 5/10 And Again Mate Well Done Wish I Could Draw Like That

Answer 4

The 2000 one is better in my opinion..

Answer 5

They're pretty good. I'll say 7/10.

Answer 6

if im honest i prefer the 2000 one, its more visceral  

Answer 7

I like the first one best by far because of it's detail.  I think the tubing in his shoulder/neck was really fantastic as well as the extra detail in his abs.  I think you blended the biological and robotic elements well in the first one.  Nice!  9/10

The second one was more balanced/semetrical as far as basic shape, which I liked, but it seemed lacking in personality.  You made the details too alike on either side, so in some respects too semetrical.  So 6/10

The last one was my least favorite.  Not many details and I think he was less of a machine/man mix and more of a dude with some things attached to him.  4/10

Cool beans with all of the drawings!

Answer 8

they are all great, my personal favorite is the one from 2000.

Answer 9

12/10 for the first.

11/10 for the second.

10/10 for the third.

Can't fault them. Well done you!

Answer 10

7/10

5/10

2/10

i think you shoud go get a girlfriend