What do you think of this fantasy trade?

Question

I get:

Vince Young

Heath Miller

I give up:

Jeremy Shockey

My other QB's are Rivers and Aaron Rodgers

My backup TE is Leonard Pope

Answer 1

Brees is shockeys QB now i would never get rid of him

Answer 2

You are silly if you do this trade. Shockey will have at least 8 TD's this year. Rivers is going to be a good QB and with the receiving corp that Rodgers has he really cant fail.  

Answer 3

No go, I like Rivers as your QB, & who knows Rodgers isn't bad, just unproven. Young's got mad talent but he has no receivers & he needs to show he can bounce back from last year, and Miller's good, but Roethlisberger, Willie Parker, Hines Ward, Rashard Mendenhall (in goal line situations), & even Santonio Holmes are the Steelers central offensive options, then comes Miller.

Shockey's in a prolific offense, possibly the best in the NFC, with Bush not really a rushing RB, McAllister recovering from his torn ACL, Brees throwing the ball a ton & no real wide receivers on the Saints aside from Marques Colston, so Shockey's going to get a ton of looks and stats., I would not make this trade.

(you might also look to get Ben Patrick, word is the Cardinals are giving up on Pope and going to eventually go to him)

Answer 4

pope is solid, miller even better. rodgers will aslso be very good and shockey isnt necesarily be as succesful as he was with the giants. do the trade. if young doesnt start out well stick w rodgers as he will do very well. good luck.

Answer 5

heath miller is good... vince is becoming a better passer. and i say that heath can do a good job