What do you think of this hadith? Do you agree with it?

Question

Imam Hussain said:

O' people , the Messenger of God said : Whoever sees an aggressive tyrant legalizes the forbiddens of God , breeches divine laws , opposes the tradition of the Prophet , oppresses the worshippers of God , but does not concede his opposition to God in word or in deed , surely Allah will place that tyrant where he deserves.

(Maktal Khawarazmi , Vol. 1 , P. 234)

Answer 1

U mean like Saddam?

He hurt my people, now Allah will give him what he deserves

Answer 2

Agreed

Answer 3

yea dude- notice he said Allah will place him where he deserves- not you, not me but ALLAH- that's where a lot of extremists go wrong when they decide to take matters into their own hands and make us muslims look bad by doing stupid stuff like blowing up themselves stupidly and thinking their going to paradise for dying in the sake of Allah...but those "geniuses" are actually comitting suicide for no reason at all...and we all know the punishment for comitting suicide...

My apologies to anyone i offended- but thats the hard truth

P.S. I am Muslim

Answer 4

This is from a Shee'ah collection of "hadeeth" and thus it cannot be accepted.  It was known amongst the scholars of hadeeth that unfortunately the Shee'ah cannot be narrated from, as they accept stories as a basis for their religion.

Taqiyyah is a big issue as well.  When a person believes that it is morally acceptable to lie, and uses the name of religion to justify it, then it is hard to take that individual seriously.  Unfortunately this is part of the modern day Raafidah creed.

As for the hadeeth, I have never seen a single hadeeth from the Shee'ah with a complete chain of narration.  They are always either broken at the top or contain several anonymous narrators (99% of the time it's both).  The scholars of hadeeth said not to narrate from Shee'ah for a reason and thus hadeeth from collections like that cannot be accepted.

EDIT: You didn't show me the complete chain of narration.  Who was the author of Maktal Khawarazmi?  The complete chain would be from the author of that collection down to the Prophet sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam, not from just Husayn radiyallaahu 'an.  Don't play games.  If this hadeeth is truthful, show me where I can seek out this book and the references for the hadeeth.

Answer 5

Please provide the chain of narration

EDIT:

Akhee 'Abdul-Quddoos,

al-Khawaarizmee was a Shee'ee, the book is a Shee'ee book.

Regardless we dont take from them their narrations because they're known for Kadhhib

وقال محمد بن سعيد الأصبهاني : ( سمعت شريكاً يقول : احمل العلم عن كل من لقيت إلا الرافضة ، فإنهم يضعون الحديث ويتخذونه ديناً )

And Muhammad bin Sa’eed al-Asbahaanee said: ((I heard Shareek (Bin Abdillaah, Qaadhee of Koofaa) saying: “Take knowledge from whoever you meet except the Raafidhah, for they fabricate hadeeth and take it as religion))

Imaam ash-Shaafi’ee amongst other Ulemaa stated that we should not narrate from the Raafidhah Shee’ah as they are amongst the liars as Ibn Taymiyyah reported in his Minhaaj as-Sunnah (1/59 -62):

وقال مؤمل بن إهاب سمعت يزيد بن هارون يقول يكتب عن كل صاحب بدعة إذا لم يكن داعية إلا الرافضة فإنهم يكذبون

Mu’mal Ibn Ihaab said: I heard Yazeed Bin Haaroon (d. 206H) saying, ((The narrations of every person of innovation can be written as long as he is not a caller to it, except the Raafidah, since they are liars.))

Ibn Taymiyyah recorded in his Minhaaj as-Sunnah (1/69):

قال أبو حاتم الرازي سمعت يونس بن عبد الأعلى يقول قال أشهب بن عبد العزيز سئل مالك عن

الرافضة فقال لا تكلمهم ولا ترو عنهم فإنهم يكذبون وقال أبو حاتم حدثنا حرملة قال سمعت الشافعي يقول لم أر أحدا أشهد بالزور من الرافضة

((Aboo Haatim ar-Raazee (d.277H) said, “I heard Yoonus bin ‘Abd al-A’laa saying: Ashhaab bin ‘Abdul’Azeez asked Maalik (d.179H) about the Raafidah, so he said, “Do not speak to them and do not narrate from them, since they lie. And Aboo Haatim said, “Harmalah related to us saying: I heard ash-Shaafi’ee (d.204H) saying, “I have not seen anyone testifying for more evil than the Raafidah.”))

ibn Hajar said:

واما الفضايل فلا تحصى كم وضع الرافضة في فضل اهل البيت

"As for narrations about  the virtues, it's impossible to count how many of those that the Rawaafidh fabricated about ahlel-bayt".

Leesanul meezasn of Ibn Hajar 1/13.

Al-Haafidh Aboo Ya’laa said: "The Rawafidh fabricated 300,000 narrations about ‘Alee and Ahlul bayt".

ibnul Qayyim in his  "Al manaar wa munif fee saheeh wa dha’eef" on page 292

Answer 6

"surely Allah will place that tyrant where he deserves. "

im guessing that h**l, right?

Answer 7

Yeah , Totally agree with that.

Some dudes just denied a fact, Just because the name of Imam Hussain (a.s) was written above that .

Don't worry about it ; Logic doesn't work here bro.

Answer 8

I agree brother