What do you think of this promise ring?

Question

http://www.uncommongoods.com/item/item.jsp?itemId=15840

Theres something about the meaning that really gets me, as a promise ring not like a formal engagement ring...

Answer 1

I like it, but I also would thing the ends would snag and get caught on things- especially your hair and sweaters. Just being practical.

In the old days, we used to tie a string around our finger to remember things..tying a string around the finger kept an idea from escaping, in effect, tying the idea to yourself

Answer 2

it's nice. but I thought that the guy should be picking out the promise ring instead of the girl.

also, mine is nothing like that but i am always scratching my fiance, myself, or people i work with so I can only imagine how much you'd be scratching people too with that ring. great symbolism, but i would rethink the functionality of the ring versus what it looks like.

Answer 3

The second one is okay, I guess, but not great. Something simpler is nicer, though, for highschoolers' promise rings -

http://www.silverjewelryontheweb.com/NoF...

http://www.skyesterling.com/merchant.mvc...

Answer 4

I like the second one best but I believe either style will catch on things and this  could damage the ring or your finger - or both.

Answer 5

I tie those rings around my boyfriend's finger all the time, lol.

I'm usually not into the idea of promise rings, but that's a really cute ring and has a lot of meaning into it. It's not like those rings with diamonds and stuff, it's simple and elegant. Don't get me wrong, diamonds are great, but promise rings shouldn't be like a pre-engagement ring.

Good luck with your relationship. I might have to get me one of those...  

Answer 6

It's cute, but I think the 'ends' would get caught on stuff and possibly snag clothing.

Answer 7

those are really cute : ) i like the silver

Answer 8

I like them. I think they are very appropriate! I picked out my engagement ring, and went with a three-stone ring, because I liked the fact it represented the past, present and future. That was non-traditional but I loved it!

Answer 9

I think it is LOVELY. I like the idea behind it.  

Answer 10

they have a nice meaning. not to be mean but i think theyre ok. check out this website they have similar stuff and you can get the whole set the like the bracelet earings and ring if you wants. the rings are also good for  males and females if you want to get him one too

http://secure.jamesavery.com/jewalry/sea...

the link dosent seem to work but if go to the  the advance search part on the top left corner and type Lovers knot they should come up.

Answer 11

Absolutely beautiful.   Either one.  

Answer 12

I too like the meaning behind. I think the ring is a bit unattractive in and of itself though.

Sorry...