What do you think of this trade? Fantasy Football question?

Question

Im trading

Chris Chambers WR

Michael Turner RB

Philip Rivers QB

Bobby Engram WR

for

Jay Cutler QB

Anquan Boldin WR

Calvin Johnson WR

Lendale White RB

do you think thats fair? and do you think im getting better players?

Answer 1

I think you are getting the better deal. Go for it. GL

Answer 2

Noooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!

If Rivers throws to Chambers you get alot of points and Turner will start for the Falcons and because there's no passing game there he gets plenty of carries. Engram is okay.

Answer 3

QB - Philip Rivers has a much more difficult schedule than Cutler, but he has produced solid numbers regardless of the opposing team in the past. He's got much more value than Cutler

RB - Michael Turner has yet to prove himself as a starter, while LenDale White's good for touchdowns, you're getting a good deal on that.

WR - hmm. Chambers and Engram are posed to have good seasons, as are Boldin and Johnson. However, I'd take Rivers and Hasselbeck over Leinart/Warner and Kitna. Also, Johnsons only in his second season, while the others are experienced veterans. You're losing out big here.

The only position you'd strengthen is RB, so unless you don't have a solid starter, don't take it, cause your QB and WR situations would fall dead.

Answer 4

your getting an equal QB, equal running back, but 2 better wr's. I say do it.  Calvin Johnson is going to battle for #1 this year and Anquan is always solid. We know lendale white is a starter, we dont know if Turner is splitting carries full time. I say do the trade, the only thing that would hurt you is if your new players got hurt and the old ones didnt, but you can base it on that. Do it!

Answer 5

QB - You are getting screwed. Cutler stinks, and the Denver offense is in big trouble.

At least you know Rivers has a winning team with decent WRs and a awesome TE.

RB - I believe you are even. Turner, in my opinion should do better than White. He has his opportunity to start and I think he will make the most of it. White always struggles with his weight and conditioning and has a QB that likes to run himself more than hand the ball off. Both the Falcons and Titans will have a multi RB offense as well.

WR - Don't let people tell you you are coming out ahead here.

Boldin is in a contract dispute with the Cardinals and it's not certain what that will turn into. If he holds out, it could be a mess. Calvin Johnson would have a chance at being a decent WR if he wasn't on the Lions. He only had 750 yards last season. And remember, they were saying he was going to be so awesome last year as well.

Chris Chambers is the best WR on the Chargers and had great performances in the playoffs last season. Now that he will go to camp with the Chargers and be fully in tune with their offense, he is going to put up respectable numbers.

Engram is coming off the best season of his career and is an established, experienced WR for Seattle.

You do what you feel is right, but to me, it's a little early in the game to be throwing around 8 player trades. Training camp just started, there is a ton of things that are going to happened between now and the start of the season.

Be patient, and watch how things play out.

Good Luck.