What do you think of those horrible Cats players picking on Freo's Josh Carr, last week?

Question

Coach Mark Harvey (he has confirmed that he can't handle the pressure & has lost the plot) is now complaining of the treatment Josh Carr received from Geelong - & other teams each week.

Some of the Cats gave Carr a bit back when he was getting into Ablett. Plus Carr has a habit of targeting someone each week. He has been getting away with murder - I'm glad to see him on the receiving end.

Knights first coach to be sacked - Harvey a close second!

Answer 1

boo hoo! i think Josh Carr got a taste of his own nasty medicine !!!!

horrible cats?...let us rephrase that: horrible Carr!

and a note for Carr...TOUGHEN UP PRINCESS!!!!!!!!

Answer 2

I think that Josh Carr deserves all he gets, but I couldn't help but note that whenever a Geelong player had a go at Carr there was always a group of them to do it.

But I suppose Cats = Pu$$ies.

Answer 3

Carr deserves what he gets - Cats play fair unlike the Hawks

Answer 4

He's right in a way.  It was horrible!  That a couple of players picked on Josh Carr.  It shows a complete lack of discipline.  It should've been the ENTIRE TEAM!

Answer 5

I think it was wonderful!

I couldn't care who snotters him - as long as someone does.

Answer 6

I think it was good that Carr copped back what he dishes out on a regular basis.

He has been going on TV of late & bragging about how he targets certain players & upsets them during a game.

What goes around comes around.

Answer 7

Horrible cats? Well I really think it should say horrible Carr. He deserved what he got and some. I cant see why he should be complaining he should be having a hard look at why, his bully team player got such a hard time in the first place.

Good things come to those who wait. And I think what the Cats did to Carr was perhaps well deserved. If he cant keep up with the heat then what is he playing for.

Answer 8

Geelong are lucky to have won that match.....

Carr is always getting into fights though... its a bit annoying. but when he's a good player.... he's a good player!!

BTW im sure harvey's not going anywhere! give him a chance... the Richmond coach didnt get sacked after their season!

Answer 9

Yes, it was horrible - that's what I think.

Geelong have always been like that though. When they have a go at an opposing player they gang up on him or snipe from behind in away from the ball incidents. They must be the worst team in the comp for that!

Answer 10

josh carr is an idiot. since he left the power he's done nothing and is not the really good footy player he was at port. i'm a power fan and he was my fav player. but he wanted to go home and has fallen to pieces. that's my 2 cents worth.

Answer 11

About time someone gave the shockers some of their own medicine, they harass and annoy then complain when someone else does it.

The Cats don't have to be brutal to win, they have talent - anything they do to opposition must be deserved - and no, I don't barrack for the Cats!

Answer 12

Dry your eyes out,he deserves everything he gets,He gets in return in what he does to others.If he can't handle the hard stuff he should sit on the sideline.Purple haze ,what a joke.More like purple Puke.

Answer 13

alls fair in love and war.

think you are off the mark with knights first to be sacked, i think it will be bailey or even st.kilda's no name coach, who has got his team going backwards from where he picked them up, ross lyon.

Answer 14

First of all, don't pick on Matty Knights because he has lost 13 players due to injury, Can't do much about that.

As far as i'm concerned, Freo would have most likely drawn with the Cats had it not been for time keeping and umpire error - far too many that they get away with these days but you cant say jack about it because you get fined; the umpires have become untouchable! Anyway, i'm backing Harv's 100%

As for Geelong, they are a very devious side, and you will often see a lot of the opposition players injured when they play them. I am starting to believe that they are actually trained to keep an eye on the ball and whack their opponant somehow at the same time so as to get away with their "careless" actions. I didn't see exactly what it is that Harvey or whoever is upset about but I have no doubt that the Cats were "picking" because it's what they do best and if on the odd occasion they cant win on their own merit, they try to knock the opposition out instead!

Answer 15

what do you think of those horrible taggers picking on Eagle's Daniel Kerr all the time?

itd be h**l playing footy with someone tugging on your shirt endlessly.

a little tug on the shirt like that in the forward line would be a free-kick.

in the midfield its nothing.

so yeah, josh carr got what he deserved.

and now he's suspended.

well done to the cats who gave him everything he has given players over the past couple of years.