What former Player on Your Favorite MLB Team do you want to Fail?

Question

An active player. For Some Reason I do not want J.D Drew to succeed even though he did win a WS.

Answer 1

Billy Wagner

From Philadelphia to New York.

Answer 2

Kyle Lohse-SP St. Louis Cardinals (Former Red which is my fav. team)

Answer 3

Gary Sheffield. Glad I already got my wish.

Here's to hoping he never makes the Hall of Fame!

Answer 4

Yankees fan, and I'm not sure who I'd choose. I usually don't root for players to be unsuccessful unless they're on the Red Sox. But even I couldn't really be too mad about Ramiro Mendoza when he went to Boston.

The closest I can come up with is Gary Sheffield, mainly because of what he said about Joe Torre after he got traded away. But I just want him to do badly whenever his team plays the Yanks and that's about it.

If Kevin Brown was still playing, I might be rooting for him to have massive failures after his tank job performance in 2004. The only emotion the man ever showed when he was with the Yankees was when he punched a wall and injured his pitching hand. Idiot.  

Answer 5

mark prior!!!!!!!!!! way to waist $ and almost 5 years of waiting!   goooooo cubs!

Answer 6

I really do not want to see Gary Sheffield succeed. I really don't like the guy.

Also, if Carl Pavano winds up on a different baseball team next year and actually finds himself playing ball, it would really p**s me off to see him succeed. I don't like wishing failure upon any player but I would make an exception with him.  

Answer 7

Richie Sexson- Yankees (use to be on the Mariners)

Answer 8

Jim Edmonds of the Chicago Cubs. Formerly of the St. Louis Cardinals

Answer 9

Corey and Eric Patterson who were on the Cubs (Now on Reds and A's respectively). I hate the Patterson brothers with a passion.

Answer 10

Joe Blanton, it's annoying how he's doing so good on his new team, but did so bad on the A's

Answer 11

In all honesty there isn't one.

I always hope that our former players do great wherever they go EXCEPT when they come back and face us.

There are some I don't like as much as others, but I don't hope they fail or anything like that.  

Answer 12

its a tie between juan pierre and matt murton (cubs fan)

as for the edmonds chick... i must say HAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!! GO CUBS

Answer 13

Well JD Drew has been doing great since Ortiz went on the DL, so hopefully that's not too much of a downer for you.

I am still upset that Pudge has managed to win two WS and is now playing for the YANKEES of all teams. From 96-99 every year the Rangers lost to the Yankees in the playoffs. So frustrating...

Answer 14

Scott Kazmir...the Mets should have never traded him.

Answer 15

I'm a Yankee fan, but I don't really know if I do want any former Yankees to fail. There are other players I can't stand, but I can't think of any former Yankees. I can definitely see how Red Sox fans would want Damon to fail and how people hate Jeff Kent, though.

Answer 16

Jeff Kent

I cringe when I say that name

Answer 17

I've got a few

Rafael Furcal, i would say Andruw Jones but he doesnt need anyone to wish it upon him he sucks bad enuogh on his own

Last, Mark Teixiera

Answer 18

Johnie Damen.

I don't share your thoughts about JD Drew. I love all the Red Sox players, even Manny being Manny, although he was traded. J. Bay is doing great and Jed Lowrie is awesome as is Dustin Pedroia.

BTW you asked a question about FORMER players, then you shot down an active player. What gives with that?

Answer 19

i hate J.D Drew also because he is a money hungry bastered. Glad ur in Boston because id rather have Pierre Kemp Ethier and Manny. Jeff Kent is one of my favorite players though, he may be old but hasnt shown it since the Manny trade. I also hated Beltre because he left for a bigger contract with Seattle. I wish we never traded Shawn Green though. He was my favorite.