What if,in the book Twilight Edward was still the same guy but he was an ugly vampire?

Question

Would you still think he was great?

Answer 1

depends .............if he still has a great personality, bella probably would still have fallen for him though no matter how he looks, she just likes danger. I THINK  I would still like him though because he is caring........ but it really depends- sorry for being so shallow but seriously would he even stand out anymore? He may still be lovable but you would have to get to know him first.

Answer 2

Yes!

Answer 3

he's still a vampire, so yeah!

& he's sweet & stuff.

Answer 4

Yes. lol.  Good question.  I think it would take more time to love him, though, because it's human nature to be first drawn in by physical attraction.

Though physical attraction to a ficitonal character has become disturbingly pronounced.

Robert Pattinson on the other hand...What a hottie!  I'm sure there's more to him. lol.

Answer 5

Ha-hah, Sheena; finally, someone who tells the truth!

Answer 6

Of course.

Answer 7

of course..he is EDWARD!! He is perfect in ALL ways.....even if he was hideous he would still be the caring,sweet,wonderful vampire...that everyone loves!! If someone says they wouldn't like him if he was ugly ..they are not as in love with him as everyone else.....I personally would still love him..it just makes him more amazing that he is beautiful too!

P.S. If he was a vampire...even if he was "ugly" he would be better looking than the hottest guy alive...

Answer 8

bella wouldn't like him, because she is shallow. the whole first book all she talks about is how beautiful and sparkly edward is. she's annoying

Answer 9

For all we know, Edward is actually a hideous eyesore.  The book is told from Bella's perspective, so we only get her biased description of him.  There are certain people that I find beautiful that my friends do not, and vice versa.  We only know what she thinks of him; she romanticizes him.  So really, this question is a moot point.

Answer 10

yea, I'm not shallow so of course he would still be great. and i think bells would still have fallen in love with him.  

Answer 11

I already don't like him. If he were ugly I'd actually like him better, because then Stephenie wouldn't describe his s**y sparkliness so much.

♥M♥

Answer 12

Yes, and I would still think the same with Jacob and so would Bella! Not to be rude or anything but you are asking Edward maniacs if we would still like Edward if he wasn't beautiful? LOL don't worry though I am sure you are having fun hearing us go crazy for Edward! LOL

Answer 13

he wouldnt be as appealing, but he would still be sweet and perfect

Answer 14

yeah because he is really sweet and overprotective

Answer 15

YES! I love him for his personality and caring-ness.

Answer 16

I would still love him no matter what.......

Answer 17

ummmmmmm yes