What is a fair trade?

Question

I am interested in getting Alfonso Soriano and/or Jacoby Ellsbury for my fantasy team. What is a good trade for them?

My team is:

Geovany Soto- C

Albert Pujols- 1B

David Ortiz- 1B

Casey Blake- 1B, 3B, RF

Placido Polanco- 2B

Ray Durham- 2B

Alex Rodriguez- 3B

Aramis Ramirez- 3B

Stephen Drew- SS

Carl Crawford- LF

Gary Matthews Jr.- LF, CF, RF

Matt Kemp- CF, RF

Melky Cabrera- LF, CF

Jeff Francouer- RF

Fernando Tatis- IF, LF, RF

Ken Griffey Jr.- RF

And pitching is:

Daisuke Matsuzaka- SP

Jair Jurrjens- SP

Derek Lowe- SP

Ted Lilly- SP

Sidney Ponson- SP

Jeff Samardzija- RP

Carlos Marmol- RP

Ryan Franklin- RP

Troy Percival- RP

Rafael Soriano- RP

Octavio Dotel- RP

Also is this a fair trade, I get Jimmy Rollins and Rich Harden and give up A-Rod? Thanks.

Answer 1

yea i would give them up because you need another pitcher pretty bad and you got some depth at 3rd.

Answer 2

Ditch Soto 'cause he's in a slump. I think the Rollins/Harden for A-rod trade sounds pretty fair. Harden's pitching great, so you'll score major points. Trade Lilly, Tatis, and Griffey for Soriano. But be careful- Soriano is kind of streaky. Good luck! :)

Answer 3

NO

Answer 4

Trade Kemp (theres many in town now) and Cabrera (not to gud)

for Soriano

and that is a fair trade for u